David Lee Roth vs Van Halen

[whiplash1972]

Heh-heh.... pretty self explanatory....

[eaglesfan3000]

Van Hagar on all accounts.

[Dark Star]

Ok I went with 5150, Skyscraper, F.U.C.K, Balance and the DLR Band.....

 

Who voted for Van Halen III??? God that album SUCKED!!!

[Dave]

Van Hagar on all accounts.

 

I agree just because I never liked his solo stuff but also in saying that, Van Halen III was a piece of crap IMO

[eaglesfan3000]

Ok I went with 5150, Skyscraper, F.U.C.K, Balance and the DLR Band.....

 

Who voted for Van Halen III??? God that album SUCKED!!!

 

That was me because Gary Cerone still has more talent than that no talent ass clown DLR.

[Jez]

5150 just as 'Eat 'Em And Smile' was also excellent

 

Skyscraper - Diamond Dave's finest solo moment

 

F.U.C.K - Great disc

 

Balance - Nice disc, 'Your Filthy Little Mouth' was utter shite.

 

DLR Band - Both were pretty rubbish being truthful, but Dave's solo disc was less painful

[Dead Planet]

Van Halen all the way despite VH3 being shit......DLR's solo stuff always gave me the urge to vomit....

[Dave]

Ok I went with 5150, Skyscraper, F.U.C.K, Balance and the DLR Band.....

 

Who voted for Van Halen III??? God that album SUCKED!!!

 

That was me because Gary Cerone still has more talent than that no talent ass clown DLR.

 

[Metal T]

5150..would've loved to had heard DLR do the vox.

Skyscraper...my first show ever on this tour.Vai

Fuck

edit: Actually don't really like either Balance or Your Filthy Little Mouth.

DLR Band...kicks f-n tail! Saw 'em live around this time w/Bart Walsh on guitar.Great show.

[cdjunky41]

Eat 'Em

Sky

F.U.C.K.

Filthy

D.L.R.

[Fat Freddy]

Roth > Hagar.

[heaven&hell]

Van Halen on all of them except the last one but I did like the first 3 DLR releases.

[bangerdave]

Eat Em,5150 should have rock more,Van Halen Lite.

Sky

FUCK

Balance

DLR Band

[KarpetRydOFunk]

Ok I went with 5150, Skyscraper, F.U.C.K, Balance and the DLR Band.....

 

Who voted for Van Halen III??? God that album SUCKED!!!

 

That was me because Gary Cerone still has more talent than that no talent ass clown DLR.

 

Don't laugh. That's the truth. And I liked VH III up until Eddie decided he had a voice and wanted to sing 'How Many Say I?'. That was a piece of shit. Gary Cherone is still one of my favourites, if not the favourite. Sadaudes de Rock is an absolute killer album. My favourite of '08.

[Doksdad]

It went like this for me....

 

5150 Great album! Still spin this one quite a bit.

Skyscraper~ My only DLR vote. For some reason I really dig this album and its better than OU812.

FUCK- Right Now is a stellar tune.

Balance~ Some very good tunes on this underrated VH album.

VHIII~ Not a good album at all. So what does that say about the DLR debacle?

[Jimbo]

If DLR is a rectal irritation, then EVH is a rectal irritation with steel-wool Speedos. And so...

 

Eat 'Em - Vai is untouchable on two-thirds of this disc and great on the rest

 

Skyscraper - A bit of a let down after the debut, but still cool

 

Ain't Enough - Jason Becker's poignantly magnificent last album

 

Balance - Okay, so this one's not intolerable, unlike Filthy Little Mouth (yeesh)

 

VH III - The CD is crap, but DLR Band is crap with peanuts

[Faron]

5150

 

Skyscraper

 

Not too interested in any of the others

[headbanger4life]

5150 - Tough call but it just beat out Dave for me.

 

OU812 - A close call again, liked both of them.

 

F.U.C.K - I really enjoyed this one.

 

Balance - No contest here.

 

DLR Band - Didn't care for either so I figured I'd at least give Dave one vote.

[metalmaniac777]

I feel dirty voting for Van Halen, as I can't stand the band, but they pulled off a clean sweep. It still feels so wrong to have voted for them though. I'm shuddering right now at what I just did, kind of like that time when my creepy uncle took me on a pony ride.

 

Shower time. Which is going to be kind of awkward, seeing as I'm at work right now...

[Jimbo]

Shower time. Which is going to be kind of awkward, seeing as I'm at work right now...

 

I don't think the french fry girl will mind.

[Captain Howdy]

Pretty easy for the most part this one.

I like Eat em and smile, but 5150 was a brilliant follow up to 1984.

No way I could vote for anything other than 5150 on this!

 

Skyscraper pisses all over OU812.

 

This one was a toughie as I like both, but I think A lil aint enough is slightly better of the two.

 

Balance had some good moments, and Filthy had hardly any, so Balance wins this hands down.

 

I'm sorry, but how could anyone vote for the turd that is VH III?

DLR was a true return to form for Dave (which he quickly lost again with its follow up Diamond Dave), and recaptured a lot of the early VH sound.

VH III sounded nothing like VH or Extreme for that matter, and generally just out and out sucked.

[Metal T]

DLR was a true return to form for Dave (which he quickly lost again with its follow up Diamond Dave), and recaptured a lot of the early VH sound.

Some d*mn good stuff on that DLR disc..

[edwithmj]

VH all the way.

Van Halen III had a few good tracks on it like How Many Say I? Beautiful song that.

[odinroxx]

1.DLR

2.DLR

3.VH

4.VH

5.VH

[DaHun72]

This is tough coz Eat em and 5150 were the best done by both in the CDs listed. Have to tip in favour or 5150 and Van Halen overall.