Controversial Hard Rock Opinions

[auslander]

Starting a thread where everyone can list their controversial hard rock opinions that may even be true.

[auslander]

I'll start.

Motley Crue - Motley Crue (1994) is the best album that The Crue released. Jon Corabi is a great singer and fit the band's new, mature sound well. If the band stuck to their guns, what could have been?

 

[Dead Planet]

3 hours ago, auslander said:

I'll start.

Motley Crue - Motley Crue (1994) is the best album that The Crue released. Jon Corabi is a great singer and fit the band's new, mature sound well. If the band stuck to their guns, what could have been?

 

Maybe if they had stuck with Corabi they would have put out some decent music but that 1 release was average imo....

[CureTheSane]

This is a better version of this song than Queens.
 

 

[Glen]

Roth fronted Van Halen are completely overrated with about 10 good tracks across all albums 

[Eric3]

Pantera sucks.

[AlphaMale]

51 minutes ago, Glen said:

Hagar fronted Van Halen are completely overrated with about 10 good tracks across all albums 

I agree

[Glen]

21 minutes ago, AlphaMale said:

I agree

I disagree- 4 good tracks from that era 😗😉

[AlphaMale]

13 minutes ago, Glen said:

I disagree- 4 good tracks from that era 😗😉

LOL.... spot on!

[AlphaMale]

6 hours ago, auslander said:

I'll start.

Motley Crue - Motley Crue (1994) is the best album that The Crue released. Jon Corabi is a great singer and fit the band's new, mature sound well. If the band stuck to their guns, what could have been?

 

Never liked that album at all. Worst Crue disc easily. 

[lettard]

Yeah bandwagon jumping aplenty for that disc

[Dead Planet]

2 hours ago, Glen said:

Roth fronted Van Halen are completely overrated with about 10 good tracks across all albums 

People either like Roth or Hagar but rarely both....personally I think the Hagar version was highly overrated and I never listen to any music from that version, just boring crap imo...however the Roth era music still gets regular airplay from me, although usually just VH-S/T, Fair Warning and 1984....

[Metal T]

Prefer DLR in VH but Sammy that guy is a talented m'fer.Great solo career before VH even came calling.

[AlphaMale]

I just think with Hagar, they were really weak musically.

[Glen]

3 hours ago, AlphaMale said:

LOL.... spot on!

but they are all better than any Roth era song 

[auslander]

The self-titled Skid Row album is better than the critically-aclaimed Slave to the Grind, and if Skid Row had released another album like their debut instead of STTG the fall of glam metal to grunge may have been less total.

 

[AlphaMale]

58 minutes ago, Glen said:

but they are all better than any Roth era song 

[martinsane]

None of our favorite bands should have released anything after their debuts...

[AlphaMale]

1 hour ago, auslander said:

The self-titled Skid Row album is better than the critically-aclaimed Slave to the Grind, and if Skid Row had released another album like their debut instead of STTG the fall of glam metal to grunge may have been less total.

 

I love the debut but Slave destroys it in every way possible.

[Dead Planet]

52 minutes ago, AlphaMale said:

I love the debut but Slave destroys it in every way possible.

Agreed...

[Crazysam]

6 hours ago, AlphaMale said:

Never liked that album at all. Worst Crue disc easily. 

Worse than Swine?

[AlphaMale]

12 minutes ago, Crazysam said:

Worse than Swine?

Swine had a few good tunes on it. So yes.

[Crazysam]

14 minutes ago, AlphaMale said:

Swine had a few good tunes on it. So yes.

Fair enough, I like a few tunes on Swine as well, but there are also some songs on that album that I thought were far worse than anything on their S/T release.

[AlphaMale]

5 minutes ago, Crazysam said:

Fair enough, I like a few tunes on Swine as well, but there are also some songs on that album that I thought were far worse than anything on their S/T release.

They should've never called that MC imo.

[Crazysam]

13 minutes ago, AlphaMale said:

They should've never called that MC imo.

I completely agree, without Vince it didn't feel at all like a Crue album