Jump to content

what has been the best comeback by a band?


ElephantStamps

Recommended Posts

either after spitting up, members leaving, poor sales, change in what gets played on radio....who was once great.....and then came back years later to show us once again how great they were...either live or in album

 

im struggling!...but im sure i'll say `oh yeah..ur right' once people start saying bands.

 

hopefully i will be able to resurrect this post and say `guns n roses' but im ever the dreamer!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure if it would be considered a 'comeback'....but for AC/DC to lay "Back in Black" on us after losing Bon, I would have to say them.........

 

As for bands that actually DID disappear for a while...only to return, I'm guessing that maybe INXS on the back of their TV show may just do that.......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure if it would be considered a 'comeback'....but for AC/DC to lay "Back in Black" on us after losing Bon, I would have to say them.........

 

As for bands that actually DID disappear for a while...only to return, I'm guessing that maybe INXS on the back of their TV show may just do that.......

 

KISS came back pretty strong in 1996 after a 15 year (original member) layoff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For Dokken to come back with the excellent "Erase the Slate" after the festering pile of cow dung that was "Shadowlife" was pretty cool.

 

Also, even though "Done With Mirrors" was technically their comeback album, Aerosmith showed everyone they could still rock with "Permanent Vacation".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure if it would be considered a 'comeback'....but for AC/DC to lay "Back in Black" on us after losing Bon, I would have to say them.........

 

As for bands that actually DID disappear for a while...only to return, I'm guessing that maybe INXS on the back of their TV show may just do that.......

 

KISS came back pretty strong in 1996 after a 15 year (original member) layoff.

 

Of course, being the HUGE KISS fan that I am, I'd have to agree with ya there!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

AC/DC immediately came to mind but I think that may be kind of a copout since they never really left.  In that case, I'll probably say Aerosmith.

 

No question Aerosmith for me. I remember the excitement when Perm Vac came out. I was totally blown away. It's Still an album I turn to regularly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hopefully i will be able to resurrect this post and say `guns n roses' but im ever the dreamer!

 

Oh mate, you poor bastard. I actually heard a bit of what will be on 'Chinese democracy' (if it is ever released) and it sounds pretty damn awful... but here's hoping also.

 

As for the best comebacks:

 

Tesla - 'Into the now' (Sensational return after so long away)

 

TNT - 'My Religion' (even if I loved every album before that, stellar comeback to sensational 'close to origin' form)

 

Bon Jovi - 'Keep the faith' (Brilliant CD after 5 year hiatus as band)

 

PC69 - 'Electrified' (The obvious choice for members here I'd have assumed)

 

Gotthard - 'Homerun' (Killer album after, IMO, a pretty soft effort and 2 average hard rock CDs - even if all albums were good and had about 2 killers on them, 'Homerun' really saw them come back into a form which parallels the debut)

 

White Lion - 'Main attraction' (after the disaster which is 'Big game')

 

Skid Row - 'Thickskin' (I think it is a great album considering they lost one of the best hard rock vocalists ever and had been so long out of the scene)

 

Butch Walker / M3 (after the end of Southgang, great to hear Butch [in M3 and solo] rocking in a new way, but as hard and good as he did before. Killer songs with much wonderful melody. Brilliant return!)

 

There are plenty, but that's it for now. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For Dokken to come back with the excellent "Erase the Slate" after the festering pile of cow dung that was "Shadowlife" was pretty cool.

 

Second that

 

 

White Lion - 'Main attraction' (after the disaster which is 'Big game')

 

I thought the tempo variations with corresponding pitch variations on "Mane Attraction" were pretty disastrous. I could never listen to that album. My ears hurt. And it was even on the video on MTV... Wonder exactly who fucked up on that one. But, yes, it would have been a very good album.

 

My contender for great comeback must be "Perfect strangers" from Deep Purple.

 

My favourite Purple album, anyway!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hopefully i will be able to resurrect this post and say `guns n roses' but im ever the dreamer!

 

Oh mate, you poor bastard. I actually heard a bit of what will be on 'Chinese democracy' (if it is ever released) and it sounds pretty damn awful... but here's hoping also.

 

As for the best comebacks:

 

Skid Row - 'Thickskin' (I think it is a great album considering they lost one of the best hard rock vocalists ever and had been so long out of the scene)

 

 

i dont mind what ive heard of the `possible' chinese democracy tracks...but its definately not brilliant....and completely different style. ah well..i know i'll love it...but i will love it as a AXL ROSE album...NOT guns n roses.

 

and thickskin....seconded....i really enjoyed the album a hell of a lot more than i thought i would...and compared to their last effort with seb...it beats it hands down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 years later...

Iron Maiden - The Number Of the Beast

 

After Paul Dianno left, Maiden regrouped with Bruce Bruce(Dickinson) and result was this absolutely fantastic album. :tumbsup:

 

Iron Maiden - Brave New World

 

Again after a couple of good but not great albums with Blaze Bayley on vocals, Maiden recalled Bruce Dickinson and Adrian Smith to record their best album since Seventh Son :tumbsup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

hands down, Judas Priest - Painkiller, the second I fired that tape up waiting to hear Ram It Down prt 2. I couldnt even find the words when Painkiller began, all I could do was just sit their and listen, it was like my ears and brain were having an orgasm, or had just done a shot of smack! disbelief! and ive never had that happen to me since.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quite a few Good ones mentioned above (in particular Maiden with NOTB & PC69 with Electrified), but for me its got to be Harem Scarem.

 

After 4/5 years in the wilderness as the very average Rubber they return in 2002 with 'Weight Of The World' and follow it up in 2003 with 'Higher' !!

 

Arguably 2 of their best releases.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Sorry but I missed this thread

As for comebacks, the best for me were :

KISS with "Creatures Of The Night" after their pop/symphonic experiments, and "Psycho Circus" after the hideous "Carnival Of Souls"

JUDAS PRIEST "Angel Of Retribution" after "Demolition"

IRON MAIDEN "Brave New World" after Bayley's era

WHITESNAKE "Good To Be Bad" after "Restless Heart"

DOKKEN "Lighting Strikes Again" after "Hell To Pay"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This year was big for comebacks... Whitesnake, Journey, Dokken, Metallica, Crue... all quality releases. :beerbang:

Sorry Charvel, your not one I generally pick arguments with, but I noticed you had made a typo, or you had some information I was not hip to, you stated that Metallica had released something of quality??? I'm sure you ment Megedeth, or Manowar, or Manillow, or something, of course how could I forget

 

Venom!!! after countless lineups, infinite record labels, and yes maybe a few below Venom quality releases, The boys hired Cronos brother Antton on drums, dropped a few extra days and a few extra dollars, and gave us the very Un-Venom Resurrection!!! for which they will never match again!!!

And..... can't forget thoseother guys that started with Metallica, that just blew my fucking eardrums out with the very top-40 friendly, Christ Illusion! Slayer, now those are some killer quality comebackers!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Posts

    • New single "The Animal" dropped today, not bad at all:    
    • I dig the new tune!  Honestly, might be my favorite yet from these guys. I like that this kind of gets away from the  Bon Jovi Country vibe they sometimes had on the debut.  For me, this has a fresh, big sound to it.   Will have the new one on my radar.
    • 3rd single... Love It   
    • New video for 'Dance'.    
    • Vandenberg - Sin Chicago - The Chicago Story (2 CD) Megadeth - So Far, So Good, So What? (Expanded) The Allman Betts Band - Down to the River Mike Oldfield - Five Miles Out (Remaster) Buckingham & McVie - S/T Michael Hutchence - S/T Roxy Music - Stranded (Remaster) Echo & the Bunnymen - Reverberation  Echo & the Bunnymen - Evergreen (Expanded)
    • After releasing two albums with AOR/Melodic Rock band Streets, ”1st” (1983) and ”Crimes In Mind” (1985), lead singer and keyboardist Steve Walsh returned to Kansas, to revive the band along with original members Phil Ehart (drums) and Rich Williams (Guitar). Furthermore, the lineup was completed by the addition of bassist Billy Greer (from Streets) and young, promising, former Dixie Dregs guitar man Steve Morse, who also contributed with composing skills and backing vocals. Eventually, the group’s ”Power” album was released in November of 1986, rather much to the vintage Kansas and Prog Rock purists dismissal, as I recall it. The heavier sound/direction and absence of violinist Robby Steinhardt, songwriter/keyboardist/guitarist Kerry Livgren and bassist Dave Hope were all contributing factors to the disapproval, it seems. However, mentioned ”Power” should perhaps instead be judged on its own merits, as it is what it is. Put out in a time when commercial Melodic Hardrock was very much in fashion, with FM rock radio and MTV as ever the important ingredients of daily life. In the end, the album actually landed at a respectable No. 35 on the Billboard chart, while the single/ballad ”All I Wanted” eventually rose to an even more impressive No. 19. Review by Thomas McFapperson 2024.        
    • They have a real knack for writing (and producing!) songs that could be featured in '80s coming of age films and I mean that in the most complimentary way possible. Really putting the retro in retrowave 
    • Gonna post this as just recently discovered them, and loving what they do. I know most here wont care due to not being their style or not singing in English, but as a Band Maid fan, this shit is right up my street. They are a South Korean band. Posting two songs. One original and one a cover (Maneskin, a band I dont really care about) which is kinda impressive seeing as the song is in Italian, a language they don't speak ha ha  
    • Autumn's Child - Zenith Nergard - Eternal White Winter's Verge - The Ballad Of James Tig Secret Rule - The Key To The World Alcyona - Trailblazer InterCore - Dreams For Sale Beneath My Sins - I Decide Ghostreaper - Straight Out Of Hell Voodoma - Hellbound Voodoma - Gotland Rachel Mother Goose - Synra Bansho Saeko - Holy Are We Alone Angelwings - Primordium Angelwings - The Edge Of Innocence Season Of Dreams - Heroes Season Of Dreams - My Shelter My Refuge - The Anger Is Never Over Crystallion - Head Or Tails Tragedian - Seven Dimensions Squealer - Insanity Squealer - Behind Closed Doors Operus - Score Of Nightmares Asgard - Ragnarøkkr Ani Lo. Projekt - A Time Called Forever Elegy Of Madness - Invisible World Crusade Of Bards - Tales Of Bards & Beasts Tarchon Fist - Apocalypse Born Again - True Heavy Nation ONCE - After Earth Crystal Tears - Decadence Deluxe Squealer - Behind Closed Doors Voodoma - Gotland Darkest Sins – The Broken Bad Sister - Out Of The Business + 1 (reissue) Bai Bang - Sha Na Na Na Barnabas Sky - What Comes To Light Soul Secret - Babel Star Queen - Your True Self Stone Lake - Uncharted Souls M.ill.ion - Electric + 1 (reissue) Nashville Pussy - Up The Dosage The Last Vegas - Eat Me Shev And The Brakes - s/t      
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.