Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Kristian

100% rated albums

Recommended Posts

I don't have a sophisticated rating system like some of you guys have.

I do however consider some albums to be absolutely perfect, for instance: Skid Row - s/t, Saints & Sinners - s/t, Tyketto - Don't Come Easy, Def Leppard - Hysteria, the list is long.

But when I don't have a rating system, I might not be as 'picky' when it comes to labelling a record as perfect.

This thread is not meant be about how we rate albums, but I'm very interested in hearing what everyone considers perfect (or 100%) albums.

So bring 'em on :-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since I started rating, I didn't find a 100% one yet.

 

 

And that occurred also with albums I considered 100% before rating them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since I started rating, I didn't find a 100% one yet.

 

 

And that occurred also with albums I considered 100% before rating them.

What's the closest you've gotten then?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't really rate with a # system, I just count the tracks that I think are great, good, average, and filler. Lets say if it's a 10 song album and I get 4 loves, 2 good, 2 average, 2 filler that is a pretty good album 90/95. As much as I love a certain album I don't really think any album is perfect. The only album that comes close is Bostons s/t. But there are albums in my system that are up there, the 2 W.E.T. and Crazy Lixx- New Religion for example,Classics like Jovi- SWW, Bangalore Choir- On Target, SkidRow- s/t.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are lots of factors that can be taken into account while rating an album, the easiest one will be if you like every song and don't skip any song then it's worth 100%, or out of 12 tracks, if you hate 2 tracks and skip it everytime, then just count it as 10/12 = 83%

 

For me personally, I like to rate song by song and added 3 factors, the production value (usually 5-10, with 5 is the lowest rating for demo-sounding track and 10 is like Chris Laney/Steve Newman production), the skill/musicianship (usually 5-10 with 5 if they sound really amateur and 10 is tight like a real pro), and replay value (1-10)

 

And because in reality if you only want to rate only song by song, there'll be no such thing as 100% because how we interpret one song to another is totally different and no way an artist can make a song really balance and equal to another song in one album, therefore for me, I can add another extra 5-10% to an album if the album really have special meaning for me during my teenage years, or like an album that you can bring to a stranded island, or maybe have stood the test of time for being around 20-30 years and you still like it, and some albums like that can reach that 100% mark :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me personally, I like to rate song by song and added 3 factors, the production value (usually 5-10, with 5 is the lowest rating for demo-sounding track and 10 is like Chris Laney/Steve Newman production), the skill/musicianship (usually 5-10 with 5 if they sound really amateur and 10 is tight like a real pro), and replay value (1-10)

 

And because in reality if you only want to rate only song by song, there'll be no such thing as 100% because how we interpret one song to another is totally different and no way an artist can make a song really balance and equal to another song in one album, therefore for me, I can add another extra 5-10% to an album if the album really have special meaning for me during my teenage years, or like an album that you can bring to a stranded island, or maybe have stood the test of time for being around 20-30 years and you still like it, and some albums like that can reach that 100% mark :D

 

Why do you start at 5 for the production and skill? That part of your rating system has taken on en even worse spin! ;) So many flaws... ;)

 

Disagree with you with regard to artists being unable to balance albums and have equally awesome songs from start to end, even if they obvious sound different so as to make up a varied album. My highest rated albums so far are Cauterize, whom I know are no one else's cup of tea, but to me they do exactly what you say there perfectly. To me, every song is almost as good as the one before and after. Another one that springs to mind is Silly Fools. There's bands out there... and they, obviously, will be the ones at the top of the lists.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are we talking about this, again?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like I stated in my first post, I don't really care about how you come up with your ratings, I would just love to see peoples lists of perfect or near perfect albums, then I hope there are some between that I've never heard, to add to my collection.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

For me personally, I like to rate song by song and added 3 factors, the production value (usually 5-10, with 5 is the lowest rating for demo-sounding track and 10 is like Chris Laney/Steve Newman production), the skill/musicianship (usually 5-10 with 5 if they sound really amateur and 10 is tight like a real pro), and replay value (1-10)

 

And because in reality if you only want to rate only song by song, there'll be no such thing as 100% because how we interpret one song to another is totally different and no way an artist can make a song really balance and equal to another song in one album, therefore for me, I can add another extra 5-10% to an album if the album really have special meaning for me during my teenage years, or like an album that you can bring to a stranded island, or maybe have stood the test of time for being around 20-30 years and you still like it, and some albums like that can reach that 100% mark :D

 

Why do you start at 5 for the production and skill? That part of your rating system has taken on en even worse spin! ;) So many flaws... ;)

 

Disagree with you with regard to artists being unable to balance albums and have equally awesome songs from start to end, even if they obvious sound different so as to make up a varied album. My highest rated albums so far are Cauterize, whom I know are no one else's cup of tea, but to me they do exactly what you say there perfectly. To me, every song is almost as good as the one before and after. Another one that springs to mind is Silly Fools. There's bands out there... and they, obviously, will be the ones at the top of the lists.

 

 

For production and skill, I myself never heard anything that's worth scoring below 5, maybe there are some but maybe I don't bother to listen to them but yeah it's a subjective matters. I think usually when a band/artist decided to spend their money into record anything, they really at least have a little knowledge about production and how to play instruments :D

 

and about 10/10 songs in one album, aren't you the one and Glen who always insist there's no such thing as 100% album ? :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like I stated in my first post, I don't really care about how you come up with your ratings, I would just love to see peoples lists of perfect or near perfect albums, then I hope there are some between that I've never heard, to add to my collection.

 

yeah I misread it bro but so far I have is SKID ROW - s/t. I have scored HEAVEN'S EDGE at 94% but this one might shot up to 100% as well. Maybe HAREM SCAREM - s/t too

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

For me personally, I like to rate song by song and added 3 factors, the production value (usually 5-10, with 5 is the lowest rating for demo-sounding track and 10 is like Chris Laney/Steve Newman production), the skill/musicianship (usually 5-10 with 5 if they sound really amateur and 10 is tight like a real pro), and replay value (1-10)

 

And because in reality if you only want to rate only song by song, there'll be no such thing as 100% because how we interpret one song to another is totally different and no way an artist can make a song really balance and equal to another song in one album, therefore for me, I can add another extra 5-10% to an album if the album really have special meaning for me during my teenage years, or like an album that you can bring to a stranded island, or maybe have stood the test of time for being around 20-30 years and you still like it, and some albums like that can reach that 100% mark :D

 

Why do you start at 5 for the production and skill? That part of your rating system has taken on en even worse spin! ;) So many flaws... ;)

 

Disagree with you with regard to artists being unable to balance albums and have equally awesome songs from start to end, even if they obvious sound different so as to make up a varied album. My highest rated albums so far are Cauterize, whom I know are no one else's cup of tea, but to me they do exactly what you say there perfectly. To me, every song is almost as good as the one before and after. Another one that springs to mind is Silly Fools. There's bands out there... and they, obviously, will be the ones at the top of the lists.

 

 

For production and skill, I myself never heard anything that's worth scoring below 5, maybe there are some but maybe I don't bother to listen to them but yeah it's a subjective matters. I think usually when a band/artist decided to spend their money into record anything, they really at least have a little knowledge about production and how to play instruments :D

 

and about 10/10 songs in one album, aren't you the one and Glen who always insist there's no such thing as 100% album ? :D

 

 

Do you ever rate demos at all? Sadly, most demo sound quality is far below 5/10.

 

I don't believe there is a 100% album... that wasn't what I was saying. A band can have 10 fantastic songs and rate a delightful 95% which is an amazing album. For me, anything above 90% is probably about on par with your 100%. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 


Do you ever rate demos at all? Sadly, most demo sound quality is far below 5/10

 

I don't like demos but demos/almost demos quality like in most Eonian product for me are probably still worth around 5 or 6 because they just sound dusty like old tapes but still acceptable, so can't really imagine what's below 5/10, probably doesn't really worth my time so there's none at all among thousands I've rated :D

 

 


I don't believe there is a 100% album... that wasn't what I was saying. A band can have 10 fantastic songs and rate a delightful 95% which is an amazing album. For me, anything above 90% is probably about on par with your 100%.

 

There you said it bro, if they're totally equal, then the album should be 100% and not 95%.

For a small 5% means that there's one song or two that's inferior from the rest. I agree a 90% album share the same strength as 100%, what I mean is you can't reach the 100% mark in music mathematically without adding the X factor unless you're rating it the easy way (100% for not skipping one track at all) :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Do you ever rate demos at all? Sadly, most demo sound quality is far below 5/10

 

I don't like demos but demos/almost demos quality like in most Eonian product for me are probably still worth around 5 or 6 because they just sound dusty like old tapes but still acceptable, so can't really imagine what's below 5/10, probably doesn't really worth my time so there's none at all among thousands I've rated :D

 

 

I don't believe there is a 100% album... that wasn't what I was saying. A band can have 10 fantastic songs and rate a delightful 95% which is an amazing album. For me, anything above 90% is probably about on par with your 100%.

 

There you said it bro, if they're totally equal, then the album should be 100% and not 95%.

For a small 5% means that there's one song or two that's inferior from the rest. I agree a 90% album share the same strength as 100%, what I mean is you can't reach the 100% mark in music mathematically without adding the X factor unless you're rating it the easy way (100% for not skipping one track at all) :D

 

 

But is almost having sexual intercourse the same as having sexual intercourse? No. Just like 95% is not the same as 100%. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest MalcolmTucker

Well, I think it's really difficult that you haven't ever heard about albums that are considered perfect, Kristian. But, anyway, I'll add three more to the list:

 

1. Signal - Loud & Clear.

2. Dare - Out of the Silence.

3. TOTO - The Seventh One.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There seems to be a bit of a thing going with the % rating system.

From what I've read the main issue looks like it's the near impossible gap between say a 90% and 100%

I could list probably 40 or 50 albums which I'd rate between 9/10 and 10/10

 

The whole 100% thing throws me off though because even at the time when I have an album I can't stop listening to, there are always things that could be better

You could even say that a great album needs songs that are "only OK" to allow the others to shine more.

 

For instance on Hysteria I'd give Don't Shoot Shotgun and Run Riot a 7/10, Excitable a 6/10 and Gods Of War an 8/10. The rest would all be 9 or 10's

The whole album is probably a 10 for me.

Same with Harem Scarem S/T

Album would be a 10, but I wouldn't rate Distant Memory, Love Reaction, All Over Again and Don't Give Your Heart Away as highly as the rest of the songs.

 

Dr.Feelgood

All amazing songs except for some which couple have been replaced with better songs - Slice Of Your Pie, Rattlesnake Shake and Sticky Sweet.

I'm sure some here love the songs that aren't my favorites and probably can name their own songs they don't like as much as others from those albums.

 

Also, over time you're tastes change a bit.

I listen to some albums I used to love and wonder why I held them in such high regard. Still good, but maybe haven't dated well.

I used to hate God Of Thunder, and over many many years somehow now like it a lot :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

For me personally, I like to rate song by song and added 3 factors, the production value (usually 5-10, with 5 is the lowest rating for demo-sounding track and 10 is like Chris Laney/Steve Newman production), the skill/musicianship (usually 5-10 with 5 if they sound really amateur and 10 is tight like a real pro), and replay value (1-10)

 

And because in reality if you only want to rate only song by song, there'll be no such thing as 100% because how we interpret one song to another is totally different and no way an artist can make a song really balance and equal to another song in one album, therefore for me, I can add another extra 5-10% to an album if the album really have special meaning for me during my teenage years, or like an album that you can bring to a stranded island, or maybe have stood the test of time for being around 20-30 years and you still like it, and some albums like that can reach that 100% mark :D

 

Why do you start at 5 for the production and skill? That part of your rating system has taken on en even worse spin! ;) So many flaws... ;)

 

Disagree with you with regard to artists being unable to balance albums and have equally awesome songs from start to end, even if they obvious sound different so as to make up a varied album. My highest rated albums so far are Cauterize, whom I know are no one else's cup of tea, but to me they do exactly what you say there perfectly. To me, every song is almost as good as the one before and after. Another one that springs to mind is Silly Fools. There's bands out there... and they, obviously, will be the ones at the top of the lists.

 

 

For production and skill, I myself never heard anything that's worth scoring below 5, maybe there are some but maybe I don't bother to listen to them but yeah it's a subjective matters. I think usually when a band/artist decided to spend their money into record anything, they really at least have a little knowledge about production and how to play instruments :D

 

and about 10/10 songs in one album, aren't you the one and Glen who always insist there's no such thing as 100% album ? :D

 

 

yep, and that opinion hasnt changed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

For instance on Hysteria I'd give Don't Shoot Shotgun and Run Riot a 7/10, Excitable a 6/10 and Gods Of War an 8/10. The rest would all be 9 or 10's

The whole album is probably a 10 for me.

 

Run Riot and Gods of War are probably my 2 favourite songs off that album :-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

For instance on Hysteria I'd give Don't Shoot Shotgun and Run Riot a 7/10, Excitable a 6/10 and Gods Of War an 8/10. The rest would all be 9 or 10's

The whole album is probably a 10 for me.

 

Run Riot and Gods of War are probably my 2 favourite songs off that album :-)

 

 

'Distant Memory' is surely one of everyone's favourite songs on Harem Scarem's debut too??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

 

For instance on Hysteria I'd give Don't Shoot Shotgun and Run Riot a 7/10, Excitable a 6/10 and Gods Of War an 8/10. The rest would all be 9 or 10's

The whole album is probably a 10 for me.

 

Run Riot and Gods of War are probably my 2 favourite songs off that album :-)

 

 

'Distant Memory' is surely one of everyone's favourite songs on Harem Scarem's debut too??

 

 

I can't think of a weak song on it.......my guess would be around 96, maybe 97%.....prob in my top 10 of all time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Strangely, I got almost the same rating on that three tracks with CureThe Sane, don't shoot shotgun 7.5, run riot 7.25, and excitable 6.

 

Hysteria was around 82.3%, I think 'Adrenalize' and 'Retro Active' are their highest rated albums for me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Strangely, I got almost the same rating on that three tracks with CureThe Sane, don't shoot shotgun 7.5, run riot 7.25, and excitable 6.

 

Hysteria was around 82.3%, I think 'Adrenalize' and 'Retro Active' are their highest rated albums for me

 

I'm gonna have to re-listen to this album over the weekend - 82% looks way too low to me.......I can see it hitting 90% pretty easily.

 

Isn't 'Run Riot' awesome?? I must admit its been a while since I last spun this disc but I remembered that as being an excellent kick arse rocker??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like 'Run riot' and 'Don't shoot shotgun,' but 'Excitable' is obviously the worst on the album. I rated it an 89%, for the record.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are a few albums that I'd consider to be 'perfect', in that I don't skip any of the tracks, I feel that the songs compliment each other, I have to play the album from start to finish, etc.

 

Queensryche: Operation: Mindcrime

Marillion: Misplaced Childhood

Def Leppard: Hysteria

Iron Maiden: Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son

Fish: Vigil In A Wilderness Of Mirrors

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Strangely, I got almost the same rating on that three tracks with CureThe Sane, don't shoot shotgun 7.5, run riot 7.25, and excitable 6.

 

Hysteria was around 82.3%, I think 'Adrenalize' and 'Retro Active' are their highest rated albums for me

 

I'm gonna have to re-listen to this album over the weekend - 82% looks way too low to me.......I can see it hitting 90% pretty easily.

 

Isn't 'Run Riot' awesome?? I must admit its been a while since I last spun this disc but I remembered that as being an excellent kick arse rocker??

 

 

'Run Riot' is one of my favourite songs on the album :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Posts

    • Dunno him...but it says this person is legendary  couldn't even be bothered to google the name.
    • Yeah, and with the January releases by H.e.a.t, Passion & GOK it looks like the new year is going off with a bang 
    • Hopefully a very nice start to the new year. I'm looking forward to it. 
    • Yeah, I remember the dude from LSD. I don't know about his life after LSD, but seems an odd choice as a first choice producer (even odder after hearing this album).  And yeah, I've never heard the other name either. I'm thinking, after this, that's for a very, very, very, VERY good reason. 
    • I've never seen Def Leppard or Poison, so their set lists would still be fresh to me. Poison only play 8 songs, though? That's soft. I have friends who have seen Def Leppard on recent visits to Australia and they also said they were still very good.  Anyway, I don't for a second think this'll make it to Aussie shores.  I have seen Motley Crue a few years back (possibly on one of their last ever Aussie shows - one of them...). I enjoyed it 'cause I had great seats and I just loved seeing them, but Vince's every 10th word left a little to be desired. 
    • I know, I know. We all know the answer but still I have to ask: So what happened to the "Cessation of Touring Contract" by the Crue?
    • Whoah... much better than I expected before clicking on them. Reminds me vocally of a lighter version of Lizzy Borden crossed with Rob Moratti. I'm going to have to track this one down.
    • from various internet sources: TYGERS OF PAN TANG will release their new album, “Ritual”, next Friday, while this Japanese edition including a bonus track appeared today. This is the band’s second recording by the current Tygers lineup, recorded with the help of renowned Søren Andersen, most recently known for his role as Glenn Hughes’s guitarist. Mastering done by Harry Hess (Harem Scarem). Tygers Of Pan Tang is a legendary band with some legendary albums, but I’m dare to say “Ritual” is one of their best. There’s a classic melodic hard rock feel all over the record, with some irresistible riffing, powerful grooves and catchy choruses. The mastermind here is original member, guitarist Robb Weir. The band’s current phase proves as formidable as its heyday, with longtime drummer Craig Ellis, vocalist Jacopo Meille, bassist Gavin Gray and guitarist Micky Crystal. “Ritual” wastes no time in stampeding the listener with the bursting “Worlds Apart,” one of the heaviest tunes on the album. Fair warning though – the straight forward chorus can stick in your mind for weeks, like a modern day version of “Gangland.” This isn’t the only instance on “Ritual,” this is an album chock full of hook laden rockers. “Destiny” slides in and the ride continues with a soulful voice. The pounding percussion is back and the riff are melodic, precise. The lyrics are thoughtful, and well written, and do tell a story, unlike many of these so-called hits of today in those other genres that just repeat over and over again. Slipping into the triple-twist of the steam train you’re on, comes, “Rescue Me“. There’s a simple riff and hook that becomes infectious, and still has you in its clutches. The vocals, clear and understandable, will have you singing along before you realize you’re doing it. The track that will “Raise Some Hell” is definitely the hidden gem on the record. This has got to be a live track used to get the crowd worked into a frenzy. Fast-paced, and rockin’ as hell. Screaming vocals, a rocket train paced guitar, and drums to match. If this song doesn’t get you off your backside and have your fist-pounding, then shut off the record and go back to your BackStreet Boys, because you’re listening to the wrong music! As this roller coaster continues, you reach the point where you just don’t wanna get off yet, and hope the rest is just as exciting. Luckily, you would be right. “Spoils Of War” might be the most melodic song of the bunch, but this midtempo still rocks hard and the solo kills. Masterfully played track. After a few more thrills, and twists, you know the ride is gaining its way to the final gate, but don’t take the safety bar off just yet. “The Art Of Noise” has yet another trick that will have you raising your fists into the air, and trying to catch your breath once again. Hang on, because you still have to “Sail On” until the end. Maybe not the most exciting part of this ride, but still an effective end. Clear concise vocals and equally as good playing from the rest of the Tygers are ever-present here. So sit back, and enjoy this last bit of this “Ritual” and to hell with keeping your arms and legs inside the ride at all times. “Ritual” may be the bast sounding Tygers album since 1981’s Spellbound, but don’t take me wrong, it’s still a fresh new album that stands on its own. You couldn’t ask for a more beautifully produced album. Presenting a top notch mix and crystal clear recording, the use of modern technology pays homage to the band’s legacy without succumbing to a thin lifeless sound. And songwriting is just as strong, as each musician performance. One of the best classic rock / traditional hard / melodic albums of the year. Raise those fists, and enjoy. Highly Recommended Tracklist: 01 – Worlds Apart 02 – Destiny 03 – Rescue Me 04 – Raise Some Hell 05 – Spoils of War 06 – White Lines 07 – Words Cut Like Knives 08 – Damn You! 09 – Love Will Find a Way 10 – Art of Noise 11 – Sail On JAPAN BONUS TRACK: 12 – Don’t Touch Me There (2019 Version) Robb Weir – Guitars Craig Ellis – Drums Jack Meille – Vocals Gavin Gray – Bass Micky Crystal – Guitars   BUY IT www.cdjapan.co.jp/product/MICP-11527    
    • Well, I can't wait for it.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.