Okay, I haven't read through all 13 pages of this thread, so forgive me if I might point out something, that has already been mentioned.
I love this record, imo it's on par with Address the Nation. My favorite songs are Dangerous Ground (sounds like it was written for Kenny), Come Clean, Victory, Rise, Nothing To Say and One By One which are all near perfect to these ears.
The rest are well above average as well, with We Are Gods probably being my least favorite (it sounds like a leftover from the Into the Great Unknown record). Rock Your Body reminds me of Firehouse.
Definitely a strong contester for album of the year.