Jump to content

L.A. Guns vs. L.A. Guns


heaven&hell

Recommended Posts

As most of us know, there are currently two versions of L.A. Guns touring and recording.

I think this is really fucking stupid and IMO Traci lost his right to be in L.A. Guns when he quit his own band.

 

First off this guy walks out the door after they record one of their best albums(Waking the Dead) and then years later he can't get into any other band and pissed everyone else off so he starts a seperate band also called L.A. Guns.

 

Second the fact that he says his version is all original memebers is just stupid IMO. Just because Paul Black sang for the band when they played shitty clubs and co-wrote some songs doesn't exactly give them the right to say "hey look at us were original members". He was fired for a reason, that's because one he was on drugs and two he isn't as good a singer as Phil Lewis. This is like Dave Murray leaving Iron Maiden and going and getting whoever the singer was before Paul Dianno(Dennis Wilcock???) and saying "hey were original Iron Maiden members and were called Iron Maiden too". Yes Paul was in the band at one time but he never sang one note on a cd so it don't count IMO. To often we see guys like Al Atkins from Judas Priest and whatever the guys name was that was the singer from AC/DC before Bon Scott was, using "Former singer of ............". These guys never sang on any of these bands cds so it don't give them the right to make fans think it's the real deal.

 

When Traci quit the band to join Brides of Destruction(what a great choice that was) he left L.A. Guns in horrible shape screwing them out of a major tour with Alice Cooper and right when a new album was being released. He was given the opportunity to do both but chose not to and he even said that the Guns should continue on without him and gave them his full blessing.

 

It's hard enough for these bands to make a living but it's even harder when there's two versions of the same band. I don't know about everyone else but I would rather hear Phil Lewis sing the songs that he sang on not hear Traci play some other guy singing L.A. Guns songs. It would be one thing if Phil left the group like he did before and Traci moved on with other vocalist like Jizzy Pearl. But the case is that Traci left the band gave the band his blessing to move on with another guitarist and now he wants his piece of the pie.

 

The worst part about this is the fans are being ripped off IMO. I'm sure 99 of the 100 people(on a good night) that show up to see L.A. Guns are expecting to see Phil Lewis and company not Paul Black.

 

I saw that L.A. Guns were playing in my area recently and I wasn't sure which version it was so I passed.

I'm sure the clubs that are putting on the concerts don't even know there's two versions of this band.

 

OKay I got that out of my system. :soapbox:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 98
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Screw Tracii. The only L.A. Guns I wanna hear has Phil Lewis on vocals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is definite flame bait and in the right place. I really wish people would stop talking about the whole L.A. Guns thing. Every time I hear about it it pisses me off. I've stated my opinion on this too many times already. I'll do it again because someone has to be on the other side. L.A. Guns with Phil Lewis sucks. No matter how you slice it they just plain suck. Also, how can you call any L.A. Guns band the original one? They've had like 500 hundred members over the years. What lineup can you point to and call it the original one? If you look at the guys who made the band what it was it comes down to Tracii and Phil. The 2 guys are in different versions of the band so it's not possible to say which one is the real one. It's not Paul Black, the guy who once upon a time was in L.A. Guns, and a couple random guys claiming to be the real L.A. Guns, but 2 guys that have equal rights in the fans eyes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is definite flame bait and in the right place. I really wish people would stop talking about the whole L.A. Guns thing. Every time I hear about it it pisses me off. I've stated my opinion on this too many times already. I'll do it again because someone has to be on the other side. L.A. Guns with Phil Lewis sucks. No matter how you slice it they just plain suck. Also, how can you call any L.A. Guns band the original one? They've had like 500 hundred members over the years. What lineup can you point to and call it the original one? If you look at the guys who made the band what it was it comes down to Tracii and Phil. The 2 guys are in different versions of the band so it's not possible to say which one is the real one. It's not Paul Black, the guy who once upon a time was in L.A. Guns, and a couple random guys claiming to be the real L.A. Guns, but 2 guys that have equal rights in the fans eyes.

Well IMO Phil is the singer of LA Guns...Paul Black-Crackhead couldn't sing to save his life...

yeah he helped write a few songs but that's all. Phil gave em the melodies, lyrics, time,dedication, etc..

Paul..loser. Tracii..well he,like Tommy Lee is chasing what ever is popular..poser...

No there is no "true LA Guns...but the closest is Phil's version, Which happens to have

Steve Riley, who is 1/2 owner of the LA Guns name...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is definite flame bait and in the right place. I really wish people would stop talking about the whole L.A. Guns thing. Every time I hear about it it pisses me off. I've stated my opinion on this too many times already. I'll do it again because someone has to be on the other side. L.A. Guns with Phil Lewis sucks. No matter how you slice it they just plain suck. Also, how can you call any L.A. Guns band the original one? They've had like 500 hundred members over the years. What lineup can you point to and call it the original one? If you look at the guys who made the band what it was it comes down to Tracii and Phil. The 2 guys are in different versions of the band so it's not possible to say which one is the real one. It's not Paul Black, the guy who once upon a time was in L.A. Guns, and a couple random guys claiming to be the real L.A. Guns, but 2 guys that have equal rights in the fans eyes.

 

 

The L.A. Guns is Phil's version since Tracii quit.

No one fired him he walked away and gave them his blessing to continue on without him.

 

Yeah I would love for it to be Tracii, Phil, Steve, Mick(my fav member of the band and the Izzy Stradlin of LA Guns), and Kelly. But it aint ever gonna happen.

 

Tracii should of known better then to leave LA Guns. He kept the band going when he was all that was left but when they finally get Phil back and make a couple great albums back to back he then walks away. What a fucking moron. The guy has burned every bridge there is to burn. He should of came crawling back to Steve and Phil and begged for his job back but no instead he has to start another version of the band that he quit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I back Wes' comments 100%. LA Guns is Phil now. No question. Great guy. Met him a couple of times and more than cordial. Tales From The Strip is another great album. They have more than busted their way into modern times. I will buy everything that the Phil fronted band puts out. No Tracii Guns. I have met Tracii and he was a very nice to me. But he needed to stick with Phil IMHO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is only one LA Guns in my eyes, and only one LA Guns is all over my Ipod... and each one of those songs has Phil Lewis on vocals. IMO there is no LA Guns without Phil Lewis.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Theres a similar issue with the Angels - there are two touring and recording bands featuring past and present members.

 

Ive also read quite a lot that a similar odd issue surrounds the Little River Band... that the actual Little River Band touring the states now doesnt actually contain any of the band members anymore, but they own the name. The original members now have to use the name "Burt Shorock and Goble" or something...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've seen both versions, and I can truly say that Phil's band SMOKES Tracii's version. Stacy Blades plays circles around Tracii and actually plays Tracii's material better than Tracii these days. On top of that, Stacy is a pretty damn nice guy and took the time, along with the rest of the band, to sit and chat with everyone after the show. Phil was a very humble and nice guy as well as Adam Hamilton, and oddly enough, Steve Riley almost seemed shy in a way. He was great. All the guys took the time to sign CD's, shirts, take pics, etc... I never saw hide nore hair of Tracii's version after their show... :whistle:

 

 

If Tracii would have been smart, he would have left on good terms, gave them all a good blessing o carry on without him, BUT, also make sure the door was left unlocked for him to make a return if needed. From the stories I've read on the internet and from other bands, Tracii has a bad habit of burning MANY bridges right behind him as he goes through life. :screwy:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've seen both versions, and I can truly say that Phil's band SMOKES Tracii's version. Stacy Blades plays circles around Tracii and actually plays Tracii's material better than Tracii these days. On top of that, Stacy is a pretty damn nice guy and took the time, along with the rest of the band, to sit and chat with everyone after the show. Phil was a very humble and nice guy as well as Adam Hamilton, and oddly enough, Steve Riley almost seemed shy in a way. He was great. All the guys took the time to sign CD's, shirts, take pics, etc... I never saw hide nore hair of Tracii's version after their show... :whistle:

 

 

If Tracii would have been smart, he would have left on good terms, gave them all a good blessing o carry on without him, BUT, also make sure the door was left unlocked for him to make a return if needed. From the stories I've read on the internet and from other bands, Tracii has a bad habit of burning MANY bridges right behind him as he goes through life. :screwy:

 

I had the exact same experience as T-Bone. The version with Phil/Steve/Stacy and the new bass player just flat out rocks. They were all very nice and took time to meet us all. Phil IS the voice of LA Guns. I love Tracii and his playing. But it really looks like he burns every bridge when he is in a band. Maybe that's why DJ Ashba plays on the new Sixx AM and not Tracii.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Odd that everyone is taking Lewis's side here. It's the complete opposite on Metal Sludge.

For me it’s an easy pick when one of them is releasing great music and the other hasn’t really released anything good for a long, long time. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Odd that everyone is taking Lewis's side here. It's the complete opposite on Metal Sludge.

 

The Sludgies have pretty much the same collective IQ's as the posters on Blabbermouth :whistle:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Odd that everyone is taking Lewis's side here. It's the complete opposite on Metal Sludge.

For me it’s an easy pick when one of them is releasing great music and the other hasn’t really released anything good for a long, long time. :)

 

Don't you mean ever? L.A. Guns has never released anything good. A couple decent tracks on Cocked & Loaded and a by the numbers release with Hollywood Vampires. I can only imagine how bad the other releases are.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Odd that everyone is taking Lewis's side here. It's the complete opposite on Metal Sludge.

For me it’s an easy pick when one of them is releasing great music and the other hasn’t really released anything good for a long, long time. :)

 

Don't you mean ever? L.A. Guns has never released anything good. A couple decent tracks on Cocked & Loaded and a by the numbers release with Hollywood Vampires. I can only imagine how bad the other releases are.

 

 

Knowing how much you love Hair Metal it suprises me to see you say that. :unsure:

 

IMO their first four releases are almost perfect and the last 3 since Lewis' return are all great too.

The debut IMO is one of the greatest Sleaze albums of all time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Odd that everyone is taking Lewis's side here. It's the complete opposite on Metal Sludge.

For me it’s an easy pick when one of them is releasing great music and the other hasn’t really released anything good for a long, long time. :)

 

Don't you mean ever? L.A. Guns has never released anything good. A couple decent tracks on Cocked & Loaded and a by the numbers release with Hollywood Vampires. I can only imagine how bad the other releases are.

 

 

Knowing how much you love Hair Metal it suprises me to see you say that. :unsure:

 

IMO their first four releases are almost perfect and the last 3 since Lewis' return are all great too.

The debut IMO is one of the greatest Sleaze albums of all time.

Yeah, I really can't understand it either knowing Jacob's tastes. I agree 100% with your analysis there, Wes... and even 'Man in the moon' is a pretty damn fine disc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all about the way Phil sings. He sounds like he should be fronting a band like Big Bang Babies or Queeny Blast Pop. He's certainly not a sleaze calibur singer. If I'm listening to a sleaze band I want to hear a singer like Jason McMaster not some sugar coated candy glam guy. Phil's voice just doesn't fit with what the band proclaims to be. With all of that said I do have to admit that I thought Torme was alright.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all about the way Phil sings. He sounds like he should be fronting a band like Big Bang Babies or Queeny Blast Pop. He's certainly not a sleaze calibur singer.

 

Kinda odd since Phil basically helped INVENT the sleaze style... those first two L.A. Guns albums are still so dirty that you feel like you need to wash your hands after listening... :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all about the way Phil sings. He sounds like he should be fronting a band like Big Bang Babies or Queeny Blast Pop. He's certainly not a sleaze calibur singer.

 

Kinda odd since Phil basically helped INVENT the sleaze style... those first two L.A. Guns albums are still so dirty that you feel like you need to wash your hands after listening... :)

Backed...and don't forget the 2 Girl albums..both are great...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all about the way Phil sings. He sounds like he should be fronting a band like Big Bang Babies or Queeny Blast Pop. He's certainly not a sleaze calibur singer.

 

Kinda odd since Phil basically helped INVENT the sleaze style... those first two L.A. Guns albums are still so dirty that you feel like you need to wash your hands after listening... :)

Backed...and don't forget the 2 Girl albums..both are great...

 

Backed, and still the best stuff he has done IMO. There are 3 though, 'Killing Time ' being the 3rd one. :beerbang:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Posts

    • I dig the new tune!  Honestly, might be my favorite yet from these guys. I like that this kind of gets away from the  Bon Jovi Country vibe they sometimes had on the debut.  For me, this has a fresh, big sound to it.   Will have the new one on my radar.
    • 3rd single... Love It   
    • New video for 'Dance'.    
    • Vandenberg - Sin Chicago - The Chicago Story (2 CD) Megadeth - So Far, So Good, So What? (Expanded) The Allman Betts Band - Down to the River Mike Oldfield - Five Miles Out (Remaster) Buckingham & McVie - S/T Michael Hutchence - S/T Roxy Music - Stranded (Remaster) Echo & the Bunnymen - Reverberation  Echo & the Bunnymen - Evergreen (Expanded)
    • After releasing two albums with AOR/Melodic Rock band Streets, ”1st” (1983) and ”Crimes In Mind” (1985), lead singer and keyboardist Steve Walsh returned to Kansas, to revive the band along with original members Phil Ehart (drums) and Rich Williams (Guitar). Furthermore, the lineup was completed by the addition of bassist Billy Greer (from Streets) and young, promising, former Dixie Dregs guitar man Steve Morse, who also contributed with composing skills and backing vocals. Eventually, the group’s ”Power” album was released in November of 1986, rather much to the vintage Kansas and Prog Rock purists dismissal, as I recall it. The heavier sound/direction and absence of violinist Robby Steinhardt, songwriter/keyboardist/guitarist Kerry Livgren and bassist Dave Hope were all contributing factors to the disapproval, it seems. However, mentioned ”Power” should perhaps instead be judged on its own merits, as it is what it is. Put out in a time when commercial Melodic Hardrock was very much in fashion, with FM rock radio and MTV as ever the important ingredients of daily life. In the end, the album actually landed at a respectable No. 35 on the Billboard chart, while the single/ballad ”All I Wanted” eventually rose to an even more impressive No. 19. Review by Thomas McFapperson 2024.        
    • They have a real knack for writing (and producing!) songs that could be featured in '80s coming of age films and I mean that in the most complimentary way possible. Really putting the retro in retrowave 
    • Gonna post this as just recently discovered them, and loving what they do. I know most here wont care due to not being their style or not singing in English, but as a Band Maid fan, this shit is right up my street. They are a South Korean band. Posting two songs. One original and one a cover (Maneskin, a band I dont really care about) which is kinda impressive seeing as the song is in Italian, a language they don't speak ha ha  
    • Autumn's Child - Zenith Nergard - Eternal White Winter's Verge - The Ballad Of James Tig Secret Rule - The Key To The World Alcyona - Trailblazer InterCore - Dreams For Sale Beneath My Sins - I Decide Ghostreaper - Straight Out Of Hell Voodoma - Hellbound Voodoma - Gotland Rachel Mother Goose - Synra Bansho Saeko - Holy Are We Alone Angelwings - Primordium Angelwings - The Edge Of Innocence Season Of Dreams - Heroes Season Of Dreams - My Shelter My Refuge - The Anger Is Never Over Crystallion - Head Or Tails Tragedian - Seven Dimensions Squealer - Insanity Squealer - Behind Closed Doors Operus - Score Of Nightmares Asgard - Ragnarøkkr Ani Lo. Projekt - A Time Called Forever Elegy Of Madness - Invisible World Crusade Of Bards - Tales Of Bards & Beasts Tarchon Fist - Apocalypse Born Again - True Heavy Nation ONCE - After Earth Crystal Tears - Decadence Deluxe Squealer - Behind Closed Doors Voodoma - Gotland Darkest Sins – The Broken Bad Sister - Out Of The Business + 1 (reissue) Bai Bang - Sha Na Na Na Barnabas Sky - What Comes To Light Soul Secret - Babel Star Queen - Your True Self Stone Lake - Uncharted Souls M.ill.ion - Electric + 1 (reissue) Nashville Pussy - Up The Dosage The Last Vegas - Eat Me Shev And The Brakes - s/t      
    • Lionheart - The Grace Of A Dragonfly
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.