Jump to content

Anyone hate the modern stuff?


JamesEagle
 Share

Recommended Posts

:lame:

Just wondering whether anyone else hates 'modern' sounding rock and metal? Looking at other threads, including Geoff's list of the top albums in the genre, it seems that most people on here like the modern stuff, but I can't stand it. It's like fingernails across a blackboard, it all sounds whiny and generic to me, no better than mass produced pop, even the stuff that seems to be highly rated by HH legends.

 

:soapbox:

 

Any kindred spirits, or am I sitting on my own in the corner on this one?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 65
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Knew you'd bite! :P

 

Will have a blast this evening and get back to you...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't hate it but don't have much time for it either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't hate it but don't have much time for it either.

 

Backed !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry mate, I LOVE Modern Rock/Metal. I completely understand why those who grew-up on 80's/90's MHR don't like it (a lot of my friends are in this category) but I got a bit dispirited by the quality of the new releases from the 80's/90's bands so checked out a few Modern Rock/Metal bands and the rest is history! In fact I actually prefer a lot of the Modern Metal acts (Metalcore/Screamo stuff) to those from the 80's, the quality of musicianship in some of these bands is incredible - even if they take themselves a bit too seriously compared to the older acts. I do understand those who criticise this stuff though, as if it weren't for the frankly terrible quality of AOR/MHR releases in the past 10 years or so then I probably wouldn't like any of it either...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like both, but if it aint got a hook its dead in the water.

 

Its all about the hooks mate.

 

& to be honest the new Story Of The Year album released earlier this year has about 3 or 4 dead set killer MHR tracks complete with stunning choruses and solos that 90% of people on this site would love, if they'd just give it a chance.

 

Over and out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry mate, I LOVE Modern Rock/Metal. I completely understand why those who grew-up on 80's/90's MHR don't like it (a lot of my friends are in this category) but I got a bit dispirited by the quality of the new releases from the 80's/90's bands so checked out a few Modern Rock/Metal bands and the rest is history! In fact I actually prefer a lot of the Modern Metal acts (Metalcore/Screamo stuff) to those from the 80's, the quality of musicianship in some of these bands is incredible - even if they take themselves a bit too seriously compared to the older acts. I do understand those who criticise this stuff though, as if it weren't for the frankly terrible quality of AOR/MHR releases in the past 10 years or so then I probably wouldn't like any of it either...

Yeah, the simple fact at the end of the day is that hell yes there are awful modern rock bands (and thousands of them), just like there are awful AOR/melodic bands (and hundreds of them). Sorry to quote you James, but I simply just cannot fathom a quote like "it all sounds whiny and generic". That's like hearing Britny Fox and AC/DC and saying 80's hard rock is all high pitched and screamy. Yes there are whiney and generic bands (does this mean 80's rock is safe from being generic?!) but there is also a hell of a lot of stuff that is not whiney and generic, but melodic and brilliant... just like 80's rock. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Yeah, the simple fact at the end of the day is that hell yes there are awful modern rock bands (and thousands of them), just like there are awful AOR/melodic bands (and hundreds of them). Sorry to quote you James, but I simply just cannot fathom a quote like "it all sounds whiny and generic". That's like hearing Britny Fox and AC/DC and saying 80's hard rock is all high pitched and screamy. Yes there are whiney and generic bands (does this mean 80's rock is safe from being generic?!) but there is also a hell of a lot of stuff that is not whiney and generic, but melodic and brilliant... just like 80's rock. :)

 

There may be the odd song I take to, but so far I'm hating the overall sound of all of these bands. So far, looking at the other thread, I’ve listened to Hinder, Marvellous 3, Funeral For A Friend, SR-71, Papa Roach and Cauterize and with the exception of one SR-71 track and Papa Roach’s very good ‘Last Resort’ I hate it all.

 

Hard to put my finger on exactly what it is about the sound, maybe generic isn't the right word, it just seems somehow more false, more manufactured, maybe more shouty ... to be honest I’m not sure what it is. I'll have a listen to the tracks in Geoff's links and check out Story of the Year after Glen’s tip, then see if I can sum up what it is that bothers me so much.

 

And sorry Tim, but I detest any genre suffixed ‘core’. No offence!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My musical taste has plenty of room for newer hard rock and metal. I don't like all of it, just like back in the 80's/90's I didn't like all of it either. Like Glen said, HOOKS and MELODY are the keys to success if you want to be and stay in my music collection.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My musical taste has plenty of room for newer hard rock and metal. I don't like all of it, just like back in the 80's/90's I didn't like all of it either. Like Glen said, HOOKS and MELODY are the keys to success if you want to be and stay in my music collection.

 

Or, if the bands don't have hooks or melodies, then just being called HINDER will be okay. :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Yeah, the simple fact at the end of the day is that hell yes there are awful modern rock bands (and thousands of them), just like there are awful AOR/melodic bands (and hundreds of them). Sorry to quote you James, but I simply just cannot fathom a quote like "it all sounds whiny and generic". That's like hearing Britny Fox and AC/DC and saying 80's hard rock is all high pitched and screamy. Yes there are whiney and generic bands (does this mean 80's rock is safe from being generic?!) but there is also a hell of a lot of stuff that is not whiney and generic, but melodic and brilliant... just like 80's rock. :)

 

There may be the odd song I take to, but so far I'm hating the overall sound of all of these bands. So far, looking at the other thread, I’ve listened to Hinder, Marvellous 3, Funeral For A Friend, SR-71, Papa Roach and Cauterize and with the exception of one SR-71 track and Papa Roach’s very good ‘Last Resort’ I hate it all.

 

Hard to put my finger on exactly what it is about the sound, maybe generic isn't the right word, it just seems somehow more false, more manufactured, maybe more shouty ... to be honest I’m not sure what it is. I'll have a listen to the tracks in Geoff's links and check out Story of the Year after Glen’s tip, then see if I can sum up what it is that bothers me so much.

 

And sorry Tim, but I detest any genre suffixed ‘core’. No offence!

 

Sounds like you are a lost cause mate lol!

 

I'd be interested in what tracks you heard of Hinder as there is a massive difference between their debut (which you could be forgiven for thinking is a bit generic) and 'Take It To The Limit' which is pretty much pure 80s hard rock and has been enjoyed by some of the guys on this site who wouldny normally entertain this genre.

 

If you want to hear some Story Of The Year then I'd try the following tracks which are all pretty melodic....you will hate their more aggressive stuff, so dont bother with that!

 

Message To The World

The Dream Is Over

Ten Years Down

 

And make sure you listen to the 'chorus into guitar solo' parts as they are the best bits of the songs!

 

Esp 'The Dream Is Over' in which the solo is pretty awesome.

 

Cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There may be the odd song I take to, but so far I'm hating the overall sound of all of these bands. So far, looking at the other thread, I’ve listened to Hinder, Marvellous 3, Funeral For A Friend, SR-71, Papa Roach and Cauterize and with the exception of one SR-71 track and Papa Roach’s very good ‘Last Resort’ I hate it all.

 

Hard to put my finger on exactly what it is about the sound, maybe generic isn't the right word, it just seems somehow more false, more manufactured, maybe more shouty ... to be honest I’m not sure what it is. I'll have a listen to the tracks in Geoff's links and check out Story of the Year after Glen’s tip, then see if I can sum up what it is that bothers me so much.

 

And sorry Tim, but I detest any genre suffixed ‘core’. No offence!

 

Hmm, interesting. I wonder if you have a problem with production. With technology so easily and readily available I think people tend to go overboard. I think a lot of music nowadays is quantised so that it's all perfectly in time and can sound a bit souless and flat. Combine that with compression to make everything sound evened out, the general loudness new CDs tend to have, pitch correction and so forth I can see why a lot of things may sound generic (or as you put it manufactured).

Or maybe it's the style of playing you don't like, there is a finite number of chords afterall, but different ways of playing them. Or maybe I'm talking crap, take your pick. :)

 

Oh and for the record, I love modern rock and metal!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't mind the modern hard rock at all in fact there's a lot of stuff out there that gets lumped in with the modern rock genre that do in fact sound just like pure 80's hard rock. The problem is there's just too much music around now days that it's so hard to keep up with all the new bands as well as those from the past.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My musical taste has plenty of room for newer hard rock and metal. I don't like all of it, just like back in the 80's/90's I didn't like all of it either. Like Glen said, HOOKS and MELODY are the keys to success if you want to be and stay in my music collection.

 

Or, if the bands don't have hooks or melodies, then just being called HINDER will be okay. :P

 

HINDER I don't find that bad actually and I even have 2 of their CD's. I am really proud of myself, but there you go ...... ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My musical taste has plenty of room for newer hard rock and metal. I don't like all of it, just like back in the 80's/90's I didn't like all of it either. Like Glen said, HOOKS and MELODY are the keys to success if you want to be and stay in my music collection.

 

Or, if the bands don't have hooks or melodies, then just being called HINDER will be okay. :P

 

HINDER I don't find that bad actually and I even have 2 of their CD's. I am really proud of myself, but there you go ...... ;)

 

And so you should be....any self respecting fan of 80s hard rock (which Tim is not ;) ) who claims they dont like 'Take It To The Limit' is being a hypocrite IMO.

 

Pretty much essential listening to these ears

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A few I like, quite a few I don't. Going back a few years I loved the Vonray and Waltham discs (still do) and I really like Hinders 'Take It To The Limit' & The Shinedown disc was excellent too, but as mentioned, those two were more straight down the line Melodic Rock discs, compared to some of the other bands we are talking about here. I must admit, that there are alot of modern bands that really don't do anything for me at all, Bullet For My Valentine & Funeral For A Friend being two examples who I find just really really dull and boring. I also thought Cauterize were crap too, but Geoff knows my feelings on them. I check most of 'em out though and give them a fair shake, although I do often come to the same conclusions.

 

Personally, I really like alot of the modern Finnish bands that are around like, Negative, Frail, Lovex, Carmen Gray, To/Die/For, Private Line, Hellcity 13, White Flame, Soul Relic etc which are for me, much more melodic and more to my taste.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My musical taste has plenty of room for newer hard rock and metal. I don't like all of it, just like back in the 80's/90's I didn't like all of it either. Like Glen said, HOOKS and MELODY are the keys to success if you want to be and stay in my music collection.

 

Or, if the bands don't have hooks or melodies, then just being called HINDER will be okay. :P

 

HINDER I don't find that bad actually and I even have 2 of their CD's. I am really proud of myself, but there you go ...... ;)

 

And so you should be....any self respecting fan of 80s hard rock (which Tim is not ;) ) who claims they dont like 'Take It To The Limit' is being a hypocrite IMO.

 

Pretty much essential listening to these ears

 

Pretty strong statement mate. TIM has always stuck to his guns saying he didn't like the Hinder disc, so respect to him for that to be honest. I can see why some would see Hinder as just another band, as It was hardly anything groundbreaking, even if quite a few of us really liked it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay, here goes. I've listened to a load of the suggested tracks in the thread plus a few others. I'm going to be completely honest, so some of it might be a tad scathing, but these are just my opinions and obviously represent my tastes only, so I hope no one who has love for these bands take offence!

 

Story of the Year - Don't Care Any More

Hate the shouted and chanted vocals, the sound is very modern metal to me and I can't stand it.

 

Papa Roach - Forever

It's that sudden, chanted vocal again. This is modern rock/metal to me, nothing like the chanted vox you get in hard rock. There is something too slick and too manufactured about the sound - hard to explain, but I can hear immediately in the chorus that it has the modern sound and can't stand it.

 

Papa Roach - What Do You Do?

The lead vocal is so 'modern', like the singer is trying really hard to sound emotional, but it just sounds fake and like he's trying too hard. Not a natural sound like the decent 80s Hard Rock vocalists. This is awful, worst one yet, as bad as Nickelback.

 

A Change of Pace - Take Care

Love the intro guitar, then those 'fake vocals' kick in. It's barely singing, like talking over the music at times, chanting at others. The vocals make me want to strangle something (which would no doubt make a more pleasant sound than this 'singing'). Horrible.

 

Yellowcard - Keeper

AAARRRGHHHH! Horrid vocals again. Talking, shouting and chanting. No singing at all. The sound is so generic, it could be any of these artists. Worst one yet. This is torture.

 

Hinder - Take It To The Limit

Not 80s hard rock at all as far as I can hear. Nice guitars but utterly ruined by terrible vocals, shouted all the way through. I actually really like the guitar on this, but can't enjoy it because of the vocal.

 

Hinder - Heaven Sent

That big, single-note chant in the chorus that is so typical of the modern stuff. Guitars nice again, and again destroyed by the 'singing'.

 

Story of the Year - Message to the World

Here we go again, these chanted vocals again. I think this is my main problem with the modern stuff, the vocals all sound like talking/chanting/shouting. Yeah, the 80s stuff had lots of chanting, but is was mainly backing vocals and anyway, it sounded different. Don't really like the song at all.

 

Story of the Year - Anthem Of Our Dying Day

The tune is fine, vocals ruin it as usual. In fact, this is a good song, probably the best up to this point, but I wouldn't be able to listen to it.

 

Story of the Year - The Dream Is Over

Now this is a good song, very good, better than any of the others I've listened to in this list. I'm so gutted about the vocals, because again they ruin the song for me.

 

Story of the Year - Ten Years Down

Don't like this at all, sounds like any other modern rock/metal track, very poor.

 

Shinedown - Sound of Madness

Nice solo, shame about the rest of it.

 

Shinedown – If Only You Knew

Slightly less annoying vocal this time, bit more like 80s rock, but still with that modern edge to it. So hard to put into words! Not too bad, but nothing special.

 

Shinedown – Devour

I should hate this as it ticks all the wrong boxes for me, but I quite like it. More than quite, I might actually download this one. Whoops! :whistle:

 

Waltham – Joanne

Oh dear.

 

Cauterize – Something Beautiful

My wife just had to stop me cutting my ears off. I used to think I was the worst singer in the world. Not any more.

 

Cauterize – Still Breathing

So generic, no tune at all, one of the worst vocalists I’ve ever heard.

 

That’s it, I’ve had all I can take. Sermon over. If I find a horse's head in my bed tomorrow, I'll know Geoff organised it.

 

Listening to this now: soothing sounds

Ahh ... that’s better! :tumbsup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can`t say I really know any modern stuff, heard a lot off the Kerrang channel (if that counts) which doesn`t appeal to me, old school and all that. :angel:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sounds like you are a lost cause mate lol!

QFT = Quoted for truth.

 

My musical taste has plenty of room for newer hard rock and metal. I don't like all of it, just like back in the 80's/90's I didn't like all of it either. Like Glen said, HOOKS and MELODY are the keys to success if you want to be and stay in my music collection.

 

Or, if the bands don't have hooks or melodies, then just being called HINDER will be okay. :P

Oh Tim, you kill me my good man! Okay, so you hate the CD, but no hooks or melodies? Are you actually going out of your way to discredit yourself and try to prove how wrong you are? :lol: Love or hate it, it has got to be one of the most catchy and melodic CDs released in the last 20 years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay, here goes. I've listened to a load of the suggested tracks in the thread plus a few others. I'm going to be completely honest, so some of it might be a tad scathing, but these are just my opinions and obviously represent my tastes only, so I hope no one who has love for these bands take offence!

 

Story of the Year - Don't Care Any More

Hate the shouted and chanted vocals, the sound is very modern metal to me and I can't stand it.

 

Papa Roach - Forever

It's that sudden, chanted vocal again. This is modern rock/metal to me, nothing like the chanted vox you get in hard rock. There is something too slick and too manufactured about the sound - hard to explain, but I can hear immediately in the chorus that it has the modern sound and can't stand it.

 

Papa Roach - What Do You Do?

The lead vocal is so 'modern', like the singer is trying really hard to sound emotional, but it just sounds fake and like he's trying too hard. Not a natural sound like the decent 80s Hard Rock vocalists. This is awful, worst one yet, as bad as Nickelback.

 

A Change of Pace - Take Care

Love the intro guitar, then those 'fake vocals' kick in. It's barely singing, like talking over the music at times, chanting at others. The vocals make me want to strangle something (which would no doubt make a more pleasant sound than this 'singing'). Horrible.

 

Yellowcard - Keeper

AAARRRGHHHH! Horrid vocals again. Talking, shouting and chanting. No singing at all. The sound is so generic, it could be any of these artists. Worst one yet. This is torture.

 

Hinder - Take It To The Limit

Not 80s hard rock at all as far as I can hear. Nice guitars but utterly ruined by terrible vocals, shouted all the way through. I actually really like the guitar on this, but can't enjoy it because of the vocal.

 

Hinder - Heaven Sent

That big, single-note chant in the chorus that is so typical of the modern stuff. Guitars nice again, and again destroyed by the 'singing'.

 

Story of the Year - Message to the World

Here we go again, these chanted vocals again. I think this is my main problem with the modern stuff, the vocals all sound like talking/chanting/shouting. Yeah, the 80s stuff had lots of chanting, but is was mainly backing vocals and anyway, it sounded different. Don't really like the song at all.

 

Story of the Year - Anthem Of Our Dying Day

The tune is fine, vocals ruin it as usual. In fact, this is a good song, probably the best up to this point, but I wouldn't be able to listen to it.

 

Story of the Year - The Dream Is Over

Now this is a good song, very good, better than any of the others I've listened to in this list. I'm so gutted about the vocals, because again they ruin the song for me.

 

Story of the Year - Ten Years Down

Don't like this at all, sounds like any other modern rock/metal track, very poor.

 

Shinedown - Sound of Madness

Nice solo, shame about the rest of it.

 

Shinedown – If Only You Knew

Slightly less annoying vocal this time, bit more like 80s rock, but still with that modern edge to it. So hard to put into words! Not too bad, but nothing special.

 

Shinedown – Devour

I should hate this as it ticks all the wrong boxes for me, but I quite like it. More than quite, I might actually download this one. Whoops! :whistle:

 

Waltham – Joanne

Oh dear.

 

Cauterize – Something Beautiful

My wife just had to stop me cutting my ears off. I used to think I was the worst singer in the world. Not any more.

 

Cauterize – Still Breathing

So generic, no tune at all, one of the worst vocalists I’ve ever heard.

 

That’s it, I’ve had all I can take. Sermon over. If I find a horse's head in my bed tomorrow, I'll know Geoff organised it.

 

Listening to this now: soothing sounds

Ahh ... that’s better! :tumbsup:

 

Jesus mate, if I were you I would have given up a long time before you did. You are obviously not cut out for awesome modern rock my friend.

 

By the way, there are a lot of shite whiny vocalists from the 80s too you know.

 

& SOTY vocalist poor. Yeah nice one mate. One of my fav vocalists period. Any genre, any period.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share


  • Posts

    • You're a bad dog, Doggy.
    • 14th September Bad Reputation release... Already storming up the U.S. Billboard singles chart — currently at No. 8 with a bullet - MORE THAN WORDS CAN SAY was written by vocalist FREDDY CURCI and guitarist STEVE DeMARCHI (both formerly of Canadian band ‘Sheriff') who also produced the track with the assistance of Rick Neigher (Vixen, Tim Karr) Available on 7", 12" cassette and CD single, all formats feature SAY WHAT I WANT TO SAY which, like MORE THAN WORDS CAN SAY, is taken from the band's eponymous debut album due to be released on November 26th. The 12 includes the track WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE? with the CD single additionally featuring CALL ME — these two cuts will not be available on the forthcoming album. (Nota Bene from Bad Reputation: Now they are !)   CURCI and DeMARCHI have already enjoyed their share of the spotlight as former members of 'Sheriff' who achieved a good deal of success in the early 80 s. After Sheriff' disbanded the two went their separate ways for a while before eventually meeting up again and buying a 16-track studio, which they duly installed in DeMARCHI’s basement, They then began working on some music while holding on to a succession of day jobs. In the midst of putting a demo tape together, they were suddenly catapulted back into the public eye via the success of an old 'Sheriff' tune, 'When I’m With You which rocketed up to the No. 1 spot on the Billboard chart, eventually selling over 500, 000 copies. "We couldn't believe it,” says DeMARCHI. "Here we were, with a number one song, but no tour, no video, and not even a band! " ' Although the idea of ALIAS had already been discussed, the project shifted up a gear with the success of 'When I 'm With You' , CURCI and DeMARCHI had been planning to record an album together after the demise of 'Sheriff' , but both realised they would much rather be in a 'band' situation.While recording in Los Angeles, they crossed paths with drummer MICHAEL DEROSIER who had been in the original line-up of 'Heart' and who proved to be attracted to the idea of being in a band again. DEROSIER then brought in STEVE FOSSEN on bass and guitarist ROGER FISHER, who were also originally founder members of 'Heart'. Thus united, the members of ALIAS are looking forward to the release of both the debut single and the album. The band have recently completed a successful tour of Canada and are currently supporting 'REO Speedwagon ' on their U.S. tour. Additionally, the band is plotting an international concert tour which will hopefully include dates in the U.K.Says DeMARCHI, "We 've been dying to play live again. The feeling of being out on the road, no matter how small the stage, is the best in the world, There's nothing like being in front of a drummer and feeling that bass drum in your stomach. It's f *** ing great! " Say What I Wanna Say Haunted Heart Waiting For Love The Power Heroes What To Do After All The Love Is Gone More Than Words Can Say One More Chance True Emotion Standing In The Darkness       Bonus Tracks Who Do you Think You Are? Call Me Into The Fire When I’m With You (Acoustic version)      
    • Great stuff. Rest of the album:                    
    • New single & video "Going Your Way" out on September 9!   𝗣𝗿𝗲-𝘀𝗮𝘃𝗲 it now https://snd.click/ntmc
    • New lyric video for 'Hold The Night'.    
    • Smoking sounds just like Uh! All Night from Kiss in the chorus. 
    • The Chez Kane tracks do absolutely nothing for me.
    • I really don't like the production and the vibe of the album sadly. Really liked their previous work.
    • Cancelled my Amazon order as they said it was delayed until 21st Oct? Ordered on Discogs direct from the record company Rankakustannus & its been sent n all  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.