Jump to content

The Poodles


Glen
 Share

Recommended Posts

4 tiny tiny weeny clips from the new album

 

http://blogs.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseact...logId=487168529

 

Not much to go one there, although I have heard the whole 'One In Ten' which is a cool song. I pre-ordered the album from their site as the release outside of Sweden has been delayed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ive been listening to this band from Sweden a couple years now. I have both their CDs and really enjoy them. they have a new CD coming out May 20th called "Clash Of The Elements"

COTE-front-780458.jpg

You can check out sound bytes from the whole album here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvnbE_kHmZ0

 

Sounds damn good!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm in love!!!!!

 

Sounds alot less Nordic sounding than Sweet Trade, Geoff should be pleased, it's more 80's sleazy rock. An absolute must have for me, I can't wait.

 

After hearing the clips I can wait to hear all of "Caroline", I already love "One Out Of Ten", can't wait to hear all of "I Rule The Night" and "Don't Rescue Me" and the closer "Wings Of Destiny"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Just spinning a promo and here are my first thoughts as I go through this:

 

01. Too Much Of Everything ; am I seriously hearing this right? Who the f*ck puts a shitty half-assed ballad at the start of an album to open things up? Seriously, absolutely apalling decision from everyone involved in this project. The chorus is decent enough but the rest is crap, but honestly, this is just a shitty, dull and boring start to an album. For a hard rock band, this is a disgrace.

 

02. Caroline ; one of the better songs I've ever heard from these guys. I really really like this one.

 

03. Like No Tomorrow ; a bit of an average rocker. Not bad, not great.

 

04. One Out Of Ten ; great ballad that most of us have already heard. Very nice track.

 

05. I Rule The Night ; sounds like it's straight off the debut. Great melodic rocker.

 

06. Give Me A Sign ; really cool melodic rocker. Again, could have been lifted off the debut. Very nice.

 

07. Sweet Enemy ; not bad at all. Slightly heavier and darker slow paced rocker. I like this.

 

08. 7 Days & 7 Nights ; average "party" rocker.

 

09. Pilot Of The Storm ; there are a few times on this disc where singer Jakob Samuel really has a Mats Leven vibe, like on this song. I love it. This song is one of the best so far. Another great hard rocker similar to the best of the debut. Killer track.

 

10. Can't Let You Go ; yum! One of the best ballads these guys have recorded, which is a nice compliment as they actually have some superb ones (the only saving grace off 'Sweet Trade' was that wonderful closing ballad). Great song.

 

11. Don't Rescue Me ; oh my goodness! Best song The Poodles have ever recorded? Wow, I am totally in love with this one. I have to admit, for an album I had no expectations for, this is danger of rating within my top 5 this year based on this stuff. I'd say this is probably the most "commercial" song they've ever recorded. The chorus is deathly delicious. Favourite song off the disc.

 

12. Heart Of Gold ; more thumbs raised completely in an upright placement. Great darker melodic rocker.

 

13. Dream To Follow ; wow, they're just showing off now. Not missing a beat. Another great upbeat melodic rocker. Love it.

 

14. Wings Of Destiny ; another great closer. Big, big ballad. Super nice again. The AOR fans will salivate over this one.

 

Holy shit, what a turnaround. Strangely, the reception on this site appeared to be very positive towards the terrible 'Sweet Trade', but for those of us disgusted by how crap it was ( ;) I'm such a troublemaker... but seriously, it did suck), please do not be put off trying this. Pontus Norgren is a great guitarist, but honestly, I think his departure was essential to this band not making another slice of shit like 'Sweet trade'. I have no idea whose influence was greatest on that disc, but I have a feeling that that whole overly Nordic viking shitty feel to that disc was probably mostly his doing... and the fact that there is not a trace of that crap on this disc, I think it might be a pretty safe assumption.

 

This disc is 10,000 steps in the right direction after that trainwreck that was 'Sweet Trade' and at least on par with the debut, if not slightly better. Great effort. Now, did I mention how f*cking shit the first song and it's placement are?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just spinning a promo and here are my first thoughts as I go through this:

 

01. Too Much Of Everything ; am I seriously hearing this right? Who the f*ck puts a shitty half-assed ballad at the start of an album to open things up? Seriously, absolutely apalling decision from everyone involved in this project. The chorus is decent enough but the rest is crap, but honestly, this is just a shitty, dull and boring start to an album. For a hard rock band, this is a disgrace.

 

02. Caroline ; one of the better songs I've ever heard from these guys. I really really like this one.

 

03. Like No Tomorrow ; a bit of an average rocker. Not bad, not great.

 

04. One Out Of Ten ; great ballad that most of us have already heard. Very nice track.

 

05. I Rule The Night ; sounds like it's straight off the debut. Great melodic rocker.

 

06. Give Me A Sign ; really cool melodic rocker. Again, could have been lifted off the debut. Very nice.

 

07. Sweet Enemy ; not bad at all. Slightly heavier and darker slow paced rocker. I like this.

 

08. 7 Days & 7 Nights ; average "party" rocker.

 

09. Pilot Of The Storm ; there are a few times on this disc where singer Jakob Samuel really has a Mats Leven vibe, like on this song. I love it. This song is one of the best so far. Another great hard rocker similar to the best of the debut. Killer track.

 

10. Can't Let You Go ; yum! One of the best ballads these guys have recorded, which is a nice compliment as they actually have some superb ones (the only saving grace off 'Sweet Trade' was that wonderful closing ballad). Great song.

 

11. Don't Rescue Me ; oh my goodness! Best song The Poodles have ever recorded? Wow, I am totally in love with this one. I have to admit, for an album I had no expectations for, this is danger of rating within my top 5 this year based on this stuff. I'd say this is probably the most "commercial" song they've ever recorded. The chorus is deathly delicious. Favourite song off the disc.

 

12. Heart Of Gold ; more thumbs raised completely in an upright placement. Great darker melodic rocker.

 

13. Dream To Follow ; wow, they're just showing off now. Not missing a beat. Another great upbeat melodic rocker. Love it.

 

14. Wings Of Destiny ; another great closer. Big, big ballad. Super nice again. The AOR fans will salivate over this one.

 

Holy shit, what a turnaround. Strangely, the reception on this site appeared to be very positive towards the terrible 'Sweet Trade', but for those of us disgusted by how crap it was ( ;) I'm such a troublemaker... but seriously, it did suck), please do not be put off trying this. Pontus Norgren is a great guitarist, but honestly, I think his departure was essential to this band not making another slice of shit like 'Sweet trade'. I have no idea whose influence was greatest on that disc, but I have a feeling that that whole overly Nordic viking shitty feel to that disc was probably mostly his doing... and the fact that there is not a trace of that crap on this disc, I think it might be a pretty safe assumption.

 

This disc is 10,000 steps in the right direction after that trainwreck that was 'Sweet Trade' and at least on par with the debut, if not slightly better. Great effort. Now, did I mention how f*cking shit the first song and it's placement are?

 

 

Looks like I will be picking this up as well. :) Hey Geoff, got "Hedley--Famous Last Words" cd yet? It rocks!!!!! I liked the Juke Kartel cd.....those guys are awesome! Thats another good recommendation from you! You should check out "Since October" They are good as well. Cheers!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pontus Norgren is a great guitarist, but honestly, I think his departure was essential to this band not making another slice of shit like 'Sweet trade'. I have no idea whose influence was greatest on that disc, but I have a feeling that that whole overly Nordic viking shitty feel to that disc was probably mostly his doing... and the fact that there is not a trace of that crap on this disc, I think it might be a pretty safe assumption.

 

Weird mate, Nordic?? All I heard on Sweet Trade was awesome melodic hard rock.

 

Im spinning Sweet Trade as we speak and if the 2nd side is Nordic Im a monkey's uncle. LOL.

 

Looking forward to playing the newie.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pontus Norgren is a great guitarist, but honestly, I think his departure was essential to this band not making another slice of shit like 'Sweet trade'. I have no idea whose influence was greatest on that disc, but I have a feeling that that whole overly Nordic viking shitty feel to that disc was probably mostly his doing... and the fact that there is not a trace of that crap on this disc, I think it might be a pretty safe assumption.

 

Weird mate, Nordic?? All I heard on Sweet Trade was awesome melodic hard rock.

 

Im spinning Sweet Trade as we speak and if the 2nd side is Nordic Im a monkey's uncle. LOL.

 

Looking forward to playing the newie.

 

I hear what Geoff is saying with the Nordic. I'd call it more Power Metal without the fast as hell drums. But the themes and melodies remind me of Power Metal without all the Opera/Symphonic stuff.

 

I'm with Lennie/Glen (why the name change?) It's a killer disc, especially the second half of it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Have had the new Poodles now for a week or so and it is indeed better than 'Sweet Trade', but not by a whole lot to be brutally honest. This, as with the last 2 discs, is a good, top quality melodic rock record as Glen mentions, and if you liked those, pretty much guaranteed you will like this aswell, as soundwise it slips neatly along side the other two without many changes along the way. I still prefer 'Metal Will Stand Tall' overall, but this is a great disc and well worth checking out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pontus Norgren is a great guitarist, but honestly, I think his departure was essential to this band not making another slice of shit like 'Sweet trade'. I have no idea whose influence was greatest on that disc, but I have a feeling that that whole overly Nordic viking shitty feel to that disc was probably mostly his doing... and the fact that there is not a trace of that crap on this disc, I think it might be a pretty safe assumption.

 

Weird mate, Nordic?? All I heard on Sweet Trade was awesome melodic hard rock.

 

Im spinning Sweet Trade as we speak and if the 2nd side is Nordic Im a monkey's uncle. LOL.

 

Looking forward to playing the newie.

 

I hear what Geoff is saying with the Nordic. I'd call it more Power Metal without the fast as hell drums. But the themes and melodies remind me of Power Metal without all the Opera/Symphonic stuff.

 

I'm with Lennie/Glen (why the name change?) It's a killer disc, especially the second half of it.

Yeah, I 100% stand by my comments on the "nordic" sound of most of that disc. If I do recall rightly so there were some half decent rockers towards the end, and the ballad was excellent. But there was a whole lot of shit on that disc, and imo the decent rockers at the end weren't really that good. I will whip it out and give it a spin again, though. Maybe. Just for you guys. :)

 

Either way, I own the debut and will certainly buy the new disc but I can't see me ever having 'Sweet Trade' in my collection.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pontus Norgren is a great guitarist, but honestly, I think his departure was essential to this band not making another slice of shit like 'Sweet trade'. I have no idea whose influence was greatest on that disc, but I have a feeling that that whole overly Nordic viking shitty feel to that disc was probably mostly his doing... and the fact that there is not a trace of that crap on this disc, I think it might be a pretty safe assumption.

 

Weird mate, Nordic?? All I heard on Sweet Trade was awesome melodic hard rock.

 

Im spinning Sweet Trade as we speak and if the 2nd side is Nordic Im a monkey's uncle. LOL.

 

Looking forward to playing the newie.

 

I hear what Geoff is saying with the Nordic. I'd call it more Power Metal without the fast as hell drums. But the themes and melodies remind me of Power Metal without all the Opera/Symphonic stuff.

 

I'm with Lennie/Glen (why the name change?) It's a killer disc, especially the second half of it.

Yeah, I 100% stand by my comments on the "nordic" sound of most of that disc. If I do recall rightly so there were some half decent rockers towards the end, and the ballad was excellent. But there was a whole lot of shit on that disc, and imo the decent rockers at the end weren't really that good. I will whip it out and give it a spin again, though. Maybe. Just for you guys. :)

 

Either way, I own the debut and will certainly buy the new disc but I can't see me ever having 'Sweet Trade' in my collection.

 

'the decent rockers at the end weren't really that good'

 

Ha, you do really make me laugh sometimes...those 3 rockers are excellent MHR mate. You need to get that fluff out of your ears. LOL.

 

As for the newie.....spun it this morning and for me its just a continuation of the last 2 (as Jez rightly stated). Soundwise almost exactly what you would expect of a Scandi melodic rock band. There are a couple of awesome rockers towards the end and in general this is probably (just) their best release. Certainly better than the patchy debut which whilst having about 5 awesome rockers also had a whole bunch of shitty filler as well.

 

One of the best in the MHR field in 09 for sure.

 

Cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are a couple of awesome rockers towards the end and in general this is probably (just) their best release. Certainly better than the patchy debut which whilst having about 5 awesome rockers also had a whole bunch of shitty filler as well.

Having spun it a few more times, we can definitely agree that this is their best album. I completely agree with you that there is some atrocious stuff on the debut. But the best of that disc were still pretty freakin' awesome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

I got my copy in today, in a modern (never before seen by me) styled jewel case. I'm fucked if it breaks, I have no clue where to find another like it.

 

On with the music. I pretty much agree with Geoff's take on the songs. The lead track seems out of place, don't hate it, just doesn't belong as the opening track. Caroline is my instant favorite, along with I Rule The Night and Don't Rescue Me. A few crappy tunes on this one, like the awful 7 Days & 7 Nights and the boring ballad Can't Let You Go, not a fan of it, well not yet. Not sure if It's my favorite Poodles release. I still think the stretch from track 7 to 12 on Sweet Trade is the band at its best.

 

I like Clash Of The Elements, but something tells me that I may be losing interest in the band. No real surprises or changes in the song structures, lyrics, vocal tones and very little guitar shredding/soloing, which I enjoy. Something tells me I'll be getting bored of The Poodles pretty quickly if they don't go out on a limb and do something a little more creative on their next release. It was like I had already heard the release before ever really hearing it. Their songs are all starting to sound too similar and familiar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

First album did nothing for me except for Metal Will Stand Tall.

 

I absolutely loved the second one. It was probably my favorite release of the year.

 

This one has not hit me at all, with the exception of 3 songs: Caroline, I Rule the Night and Dream to Follow. It is a huge disappointment at this point, but still probably better than their first one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like Clash Of The Elements, but something tells me that I may be losing interest in the band. No real surprises or changes in the song structures, lyrics, vocal tones and very little guitar shredding/soloing, which I enjoy. Something tells me I'll be getting bored of The Poodles pretty quickly if they don't go out on a limb and do something a little more creative on their next release. It was like I had already heard the release before ever really hearing it. Their songs are all starting to sound too similar and familiar.

Yeah, I dig this. I like this album and will do after this... but I started off with a potential list of about 8 songs for my Ipod. In the end only 'One out of ten' and 'Don't rescue me' made it onto my Ipod. I do like this band, but not overly wild about them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like Clash Of The Elements, but something tells me that I may be losing interest in the band. No real surprises or changes in the song structures, lyrics, vocal tones and very little guitar shredding/soloing, which I enjoy. Something tells me I'll be getting bored of The Poodles pretty quickly if they don't go out on a limb and do something a little more creative on their next release. It was like I had already heard the release before ever really hearing it. Their songs are all starting to sound too similar and familiar.

Yeah, I dig this. I like this album and will do after this... but I started off with a potential list of about 8 songs for my Ipod. In the end only 'One out of ten' and 'Don't rescue me' made it onto my Ipod. I do like this band, but not overly wild about them.

 

i havent listened to this for about 2 weeks now...but was starting to feel it was my favourite release of the year.

 

will re-visit soon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Agree with Glenn ,sweet trade was my favorite cd two years ago.

Clash is one of the best release of 2009, I love everything this band do.

I loved Helloween when Andi Deris join the band (now they get too much heavy), the Poodles sometimes remind me this German bands (THe master of rings album).

Hope to see them live, one day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is another one of those bands that I avoided purely due to their name... A fool am I.... I kicked myself after I heard a few of their tracks. They have a good sound, fantastic guitar riffage and groovy melodies... Me Likey!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is another one of those bands that I avoided purely due to their name... A fool am I.... I kicked myself after I heard a few of their tracks. They have a good sound, fantastic guitar riffage and groovy melodies... Me Likey!

 

Yeah, what's up with the lame name anyway?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

I finally got my copy of this yesterday. I'm gonna say that this is their best release to date hands down. This thing was chock full of some great anthems and a killer power ballad to boot. Sure, there are a couple of fillers on the disc, but I almost expected that out of 14 songs. I got this for a steal of $6.50 off e-bay and it's worth every penny. Definitely recommend this one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • My Little Pony

I have a hard time understanding the general 'logic' around here. This disc is easily my No. 1 of 2009. There's a lot being said about 'Too Much of Everything' being a shitty song and a terrible choice for the first track, which I disagree with. Yeah, initially I didn't care for it, but it's definitely grown on me, to the point where it's one of my favourite off the album. I can't say enough about this album--though you would agrue I already have--and I don't believe there's a single filler on it. The Poodles have come a long way since their debut, and they're easily my most anticpated band.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I need to give this band another shot...the campy factor turned me off at first, although the music was impressive...I guess I was taking it too seriously.

 

All three of their albums are great!

 

I just re-listened to 'Clash Of The Elements' this morning cos im seeing them on Sat and it is still a great album. Definitely a top 10 disc for 2009.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • My Little Pony
I need to give this band another shot...the campy factor turned me off at first, although the music was impressive...I guess I was taking it too seriously.

 

All three of their albums are great!

 

I just re-listened to 'Clash Of The Elements' this morning cos im seeing them on Sat and it is still a great album. Definitely a top 10 disc for 2009.

 

You ratt bagg! I wanna see 'em.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • 2022 HH Donation Drive

    Please support Heavy Harmonies! The donations goal is the out-of-pocket expenses to run the main site and this board for calendar year 2022.



    82% of donation goal reached.
    Donate Sidebar by DevFuse
  • Posts

    • At least the album artwork is good.      ;}
    • New album released on January 20th. New single "1995" Their last album was awesome and my expectations are high... I really love the new song but especially from 2:35 on the vocals are a bit late... the end of the chorus sounds a little out of tune. I feel like they should take more than just one year for a new album and correct things like that. 
    • Some Black Friday purchases from DDR just rolled in: Alleycat Scratch - Greatest Licks and Nasty Tricks Hung Jury - Screaming In Blue Syre - It Ain't Pretty Being Easy Wild Boyz - Unleashed! And with any luck, I'll have a copy of Blue Blud - The Big Noise arriving sometime before Christmas!
    • I don't know that I really need to add anything to this discussion as most of what I would say has already been said... But you know, there are a lot of promising young bands that Frontiers could be focusing on instead of churning out a new copy and pasted supergroup album every couple of months. The appeal of groups like this is that it isn't supposed to happen very often. When that's all you do, the idea becomes stale and the term "supergroup" loses its meaning.  And thank god I'm not the only one who thinks that project name is awful. 
    • Germany & Begium are and have been poor for a while now. There was no interest in Germany (in general not the die hard fans) as they gave their side no real chance and they were right. Belgium side is too old now. As for US, they have always performed well in major champs. Australia have out performed for sure. But I'll be gobsmacked if Argentina don't despatch them  
    • A Farewell to Arms - TNT
    • Desmond is too busy counting his money of all songs he or co wrote
    • Morocco a real surprise packet. Germany going out in group stages... I think that with big European teams getting beaten by Asian and African teams it has made a lot of the pundits who write off the rest of the world shut up a bit. Soccer is the #4 winter sport in Australia and I think would be the same in USA. Just imagine how good our teams would be if it was #1 like every other country!
    • And in further news... pretty massive story, I reckon. In a nutshell, more than half of all covid fines issued in NSW to be cancelled, including refunds for those already paid, with the possibility that all covid fines could be invalidated by early 2023.  This is obviously a positive step, but what I'd like to see when all the fines are reversed, is that whomever authorised the issuing of all these fines must surely be held accountable. I don't see how something like this can not lead to a conclusion like that... but of course it won't. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-11-29/revenue-nsw-cancels-33-121-covid-19-fines/101710632 Revenue NSW cancels more than 33,000 COVID-19 fines after Supreme Court hearing By Maryanne Taouk Posted Tue 29 Nov 2022 at 1:09pmTuesday 29 Nov 2022 at 1:09pm, updated Wed 30 Nov 2022 at 9:23amWednesday 30 Nov 2022 at 9:23am The NSW Supreme Court found two COVID-19 fines to be invalid.(ABC News: Bindi Bryce)   The NSW government will withdraw more than 33,000 COVID-19 fines after a Supreme Court hearing on Tuesday. Key points: The fines cancelled are about half of the 62,128 COVID-related infringements issued Revenue NSW says that all sanctions on unpaid fines will now stop They also said the remaining 29,017 fines would still be required to be paid Earlier on Tuesday, Justice Dina Yehia SC was set to hear arguments that two fines for between $1,000 and $3,000, did not meet the requirements of section 20 under the Fines Act. Barrister Katherine Richardson SC said the plaintiffs had in effect been forced to take the "extraordinary step" of going to the Supreme Court after other unsuccessful attempts to have the fines reviewed. "It's only at the eleventh hour the Crown has finally accepted these were invalid," she said. Within a matter of hours the government moved to withdraw more than half the infringements issued under NSW's COVID-19 restrictions. The case centred on the technical basis the notices did not provide a sufficiently detailed description of the offence committed and were therefore invalid. In a statement issued after the ruling, Revenue NSW confirmed it would withdraw 33,121 fines. A total of 62,128 COVID-related infringements were issued in the state throughout the pandemic. "Where fines are withdrawn, all sanctions, including drivers licence restrictions or garnishee order activity will be stopped," the statement read. "Where a fine has been withdrawn and a customer has made a payment — either in part or in full — Revenue NSW will make contact to arrange a refund or credit the payment towards other outstanding debts." a woman standing outside a court room talking Solicitor Samantha Lee called the decision "extraordinary".(Facebook: Redfern Legal Centre) The agency also noted it did "not mean the offences were not committed" and "the remaining 29,017 fines will still be required to be paid if not already resolved". Scott Johnston from Revenue NSW said his decision was made in the interest of being "consistent and equitable", and refunding the close to $10 million that has already being paid, will start immediately. "We'll be working through a process to contact everyone who's either made payments to discuss getting a refund as quickly as possible," Mr Johnston said. "Or to those that haven't resolved those fines, there'll be nothing further for them to do, but we'll advise them as such." About one third of people have already settled their fines, with others making part-payments while about 8,000 fines are overdue, according to Mr Johnston. "We've got everyone's' details who's paid, we'll have to write to everyone to get their details so we can return the money to the right bank account ... we'll also have a hotline. "We're ready to answer the calls that come, customer service is important to us and doing a good and fair job."  a man standing outdoors and in front of microphones speaking to the media Mr Johnston says staff at Revenue NSW are ready to answer queries about people's refunds.(ABC News: Harriet Tatham) Earlier, David Kell SC, representing the NSW Commissioner of Fines Administration, warned the court the two infringements did not meet the act's requirements. Mr Kell said the court should be "cautious" in throwing out the fines, as it would set a precedent in the area. In a statement the Law Society of NSW welcomed the "common sense" decision but urged Revenue NSW to review the remaining COVID-19 related fines — especially any imposed on children.  "Many of the top fifteen per-capita locations where fines were issued during the Delta outbreak have high Aboriginal populations," Law Society president Joanne van der Plaat said. "These include the top three of Walgett, Brewarrina and Wilcannia. Eleven of these communities are counted among communities suffering the state's highest level of social disadvantage." Data reveals NSW COVID fine hotspots A combined total of $3.2 million in fines were issued across Mount Druitt, Liverpool and Dubbo from the start of the pandemic to October last year. Mass cancellation Brendan Beame and Teal Els's court challenge, brought by Redfern Legal Centre, was the catalyst for the mass cancellation. Katherine Richardson SC, said more than 160 people had received an identical $3,000 fine as Ms Els, and more than 500 had fines with similar wording. Ms Richardson said Ms Els had no idea what she was being fined for when she was approached by police while sitting in a park after exercising with her sister. "How can she tell, for example, having no idea what offence she said to have committed with a penalty amount of $3,000, which is obviously a very significant amount of money to be imposed by notice procedure," Ms Richardson told the court. "Our submission states they are entitled to a refund. They have been charged money invalidly and we are pressing for a full range of relief to be sought." In July, Rohan Pank had his fine dismissed for sitting on a park bench in August 2021, during Sydney's lockdown. Redfern Legal Centre represented the three plaintiffs who said they received little information and the fines lacked details about any public health orders breached. The total amount of fines issued during the lockdown amounted to more than $33 million according to Revenue NSW. Most common COVID-19 offences revealed It's New South Wales's COVID-19 lockdown like you've never seen it before, a story not told by the number of cases, vaccines or venues of concern, but a new metric: fines. Sydney faced a 107-day lockdown in mid to late 2021 as the Delta and Omicron waves spread through the city. There were also 12 local government areas in Western Sydney that faced harsher lockdown restrictions including a nightly curfew.  Outside court, Redfern Legal Centre's acting principal solicitor Samantha Lee said it was an "extraordinary" day for NSW. "The state has conceded that the COVID fines brought to the court today are invalid," she said. "We are going to ask the commissioner of fines to set up a mechanism to give the money back. They have no other means than to withdraw those fines. This case has set a precedent." Ms Lee said the decisions today has the potential to invalidate all COVID-19 fines that were issued during the 2020 and 2021 lockdown. Justice Yehia is expected to make a formal judgement in early 2023.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.