Jump to content

Black Sabbath!


The best singer?  

46 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

  • 2021 Gold Donors

Who is your choice for the best "singer" in Black Sabbath? Range, abilities & moxy to belt, scream & shatter glass or eardrums, perhaps? :banger:

 

I am going with Ian Gillan! At the time 'Born Again' was released Ian Gillan could, and did have an amazing voice, range & abilities to burst eardrums! RJD, & then Tony Martin are my next choices. Glenn Hughes can truly sing, however he was only on one release, which tended to be more melodic, for the most part, with little, or not much screaming.

 

For the lyrics I'm going with Ozzy (the first 5 releases have plenty of that!), with RJD a very close second. Tony Martin also is quite good with macabre type lyrics & has great range as well!

 

Since Ozzy was the first one & in some cases/points of view, still is the most crazy, unusual/bizarre person to front the band, I'm chosing him. Although I think RJD made the crossover from Rainbow quite well, which I don't think too many singer's could do that as convincingly & kicked ass too, as he did! :drink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All of those vocalists mentioned are better vocalists than Ozzy but make no mistake , Ozzy Osbourne = Black Sabbath.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All of those vocalists mentioned are better vocalists than Ozzy but make no mistake , Ozzy Osbourne = Black Sabbath.

 

Dave,u are totaly right here,nobody would say ozzy was a good vocalist,but he was a great frontman,and when u think of sabbath u think of ozzy.I voted for rj dio,as best vocalist,but one of my fave tunes is The Shining with Tony martin on vox. :banger:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All of those vocalists mentioned are better vocalists than Ozzy but make no mistake , Ozzy Osbourne = Black Sabbath.

 

I agree. I'm not by any stretch of the imagination a huge Sabbath fan.....but "Iron Man" and "Paranoid" with Ozzy define *to me* all that Black Sabbath is.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best Vocalist is Ronnie James Dio- DIO IS GOD!

 

The darkest lyrics were wrote by Geezer Butler but he's not listed, so I'll go with Dio with Tony Martin a close 2nd.

 

Ozzy best personifies Sabbath, but he is by far the worst singer listed

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I too picked DIO for the first two questions... And Ozzy for the last one. I see that I am not alone with these picks. It would be hard for me to pick against Ronnie James Dio in anything... but for some reason, I think Ozzy was a better fit with Sabbath. Thanks God DIO did leave Sabbath... just think of all the great stuff that we might not have ever heard had he not left.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ronnie is the best singer IMO...He also is the best writer,Ozzy wrote

very little if any Lyrics(Geezer wrote most if not all the lyrics)...But

Ozzy is Black Sabbath's best frontman...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always have and always will prefer Dio era Sab to Ozzy's, so he was my answer to the first two parts... however, when you hear the name "Black Sabbath" you almost can't help but immediately think of Ozzy, so he obviously "personifies" the band...

By the way, the BORN AGAIN album with Ian Gillan on vocals is an underrated gem in my book...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2021 Gold Donors
Best Vocalist is Ronnie James Dio- DIO IS GOD!

 

The darkest lyrics were wrote by Geezer Butler but he's not listed, so I'll go with Dio with Tony Martin a close 2nd.

 

Ozzy best personifies Sabbath, but he is by far the worst singer listed

 

That is a very interesting point! Some folks may not be aware that Geezer Butler was either the inspiration for or actually did write many of the earlier Sabbath material. Ozzy usually got the credit, but Geezer was the inspiration for and/or wrote many of the best Sabbath stuff, which is why he wasn't a choice in this poll. During the recent VH1 'Heavy Metal' month some info regarding that was explained, especially about the song 'Black Sabbath.' how/why it was created. I think Geezer was probably more into 'dark' inspirations or subject matter than many of the other guys. I also think Tony Martin really developed into a terrific singer, songwriter as well as frontman as his time with Sabbath progessed. Headless Cross & Devil And Daughter from Headless Cross are a couple of fav's as well as Cross of Thorns & The Hand That Rocks The Cradle are from the Cross Purposes release, both are essentials for Tony Martin in Sabbath. RJD both made an interesting transition from Rainbow, where he had a HUGE impact with singing, songwriting & fronting that band, into Sabbath and contributing terrific lyrics & with great abilities, too. IMO there are different styles, likes & fav's for singing/singer's, i.e. range, loudness, pitch & outright screaming, and to each his own! :headbanger::drink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2021 Gold Donors
I always have and always will prefer Dio era Sab to Ozzy's, so he was my answer to the first two parts... however, when you hear the name "Black Sabbath" you almost can't help but immediately think of Ozzy, so he obviously "personifies" the band...

By the way, the BORN AGAIN album with Ian Gillan on vocals is an underrated gem in my book...

 

That's understandable & cool! :drink: I heard Ozzy with Sabbath before any of the other singers so I'm probably one of the few ;) who still enjoys many of the old fav's, and with Ozzy singing 'em, although I do agree with many here in that Ozzy wasn't the better singer, and in many cases seemed to be 'talking' through the lyrics & in concert was something diff altogether, if not for Geezer, Bill's & Tony's tremendous solo's & improvisational techniques, at one show, Ozzy's performance IMO may have found itself listed in the 'Gig was spoiled' section of this cool forum, but yet he does have quite a 'presence' especially live, whether in concert or just on tv. Ian Gillan, wow, that man could sing, scream & reach rather unusual decibel levels that I didn't know were attainable to the human ear. :banger::crazy: Some of the stories about the Born Again release are quite funny, scandalous & scary, i.e. the cover art. Does it qualify for one of the worst or scariest or perhaps stupidest (yep, there's a new combo of words, lol), or all three, heck, maybe that should be a subject for another poll! ;) both in Sabbath's catalog as well as overall? :screwy: There's probably too many for just one poll, tho!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

I went RJD, RJD, but then again Ozzy = Sabbath.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All of those vocalists mentioned are better vocalists than Ozzy but make no mistake , Ozzy Osbourne = Black Sabbath.

 

Backed 100%

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always have and always will prefer Dio era Sab to Ozzy's, so he was my answer to the first two parts... however, when you hear the name "Black Sabbath" you almost can't help but immediately think of Ozzy, so he obviously "personifies" the band...

By the way, the BORN AGAIN album with Ian Gillan on vocals is an underrated gem in my book...

BORN AGAIN ROCKS!!!! Trashed is a Classic...IMO :drink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always have and always will prefer Dio era Sab to Ozzy's, so he was my answer to the first two parts... however, when you hear the name "Black Sabbath" you almost can't help but immediately think of Ozzy, so he obviously "personifies" the band...

By the way, the BORN AGAIN album with Ian Gillan on vocals is an underrated gem in my book...

BORN AGAIN ROCKS!!!! Trashed is a Classic...IMO :drink:

 

Right on brutha... not to mention...

"DIIIIISTURBING THE PRIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEST!" :banger::drink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always have and always will prefer Dio era Sab to Ozzy's, so he was my answer to the first two parts... however, when you hear the name "Black Sabbath" you almost can't help but immediately think of Ozzy, so he obviously "personifies" the band...

By the way, the BORN AGAIN album with Ian Gillan on vocals is an underrated gem in my book...

BORN AGAIN ROCKS!!!! Trashed is a Classic...IMO :drink:

 

Right on brutha... not to mention...

"DIIIIISTURBING THE PRIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEST!" :banger::drink:

 

 

Yeah there's some cool songs on that one but for the way it was mixed makes it tough to listen too.

Also for me it was wierd hearing Ian Gillan sing songs that heavy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah there's some cool songs on that one but for the way it was mixed makes it tough to listen too.

Also for me it was wierd hearing Ian Gillan sing songs that heavy.

 

True... the production is god-awful on that album. Sounds like it was recorded with the band at the bottom of a very deep hole, and the recording equipment was up at the top!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ozzy.. Dio.. then of course Ozzy again.....

 

Waits for the inevitable verbal lashing I am about to receive....

 

Honestly, I never heard alot of Dio-era Sabbath.. Except for Dehumanizer...... Which is Excellent.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, I never heard alot of Dio-era Sabbath.. Except for Dehumanizer...... Which is Excellent.....

 

:yikes:

You are hereby ORDERED to go out and buy "Heaven & Hell" and/or "Mob Rules" immediately if not sooner! (or at the very least, the BLACK SABBATH: THE DIO YEARS compilation album as a cheap short cut)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, I never heard alot of Dio-era Sabbath.. Except for Dehumanizer...... Which is Excellent.....

 

:yikes:

You are hereby ORDERED to go out and buy "Heaven & Hell" and/or "Mob Rules" immediately if not sooner! (or at the very least, the BLACK SABBATH: THE DIO YEARS compilation album as a cheap short cut)

 

 

Dude, I was planning on getting the Dio Years Sabbath CD.. Relax..... :P And yes, eventually I'll get around to Heaven and Hell, and Mob Rules, don't worry.. The title track to Heaven and Hell is GOOD.. Hell on the Dio concerts I have on VHS, He ALWAYS sings it.... :headbanger:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, I never heard alot of Dio-era Sabbath.. Except for Dehumanizer...... Which is Excellent.....

 

:yikes:

You are hereby ORDERED to go out and buy "Heaven & Hell" and/or "Mob Rules" immediately if not sooner! (or at the very least, the BLACK SABBATH: THE DIO YEARS compilation album as a cheap short cut)

 

 

Dude, I was planning on getting the Dio Years Sabbath CD.. Relax..... :P And yes, eventually I'll get around to Heaven and Hell, and Mob Rules, don't worry.. The title track to Heaven and Hell is GOOD.. Hell on the Dio concerts I have on VHS, He ALWAYS sings it.... :headbanger:

 

 

Like Keith said you have to buy Heaven&Hell and Mob Rules.(two of the greatest Metal albums ever IMO.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderators

Honestly, I never heard alot of Dio-era Sabbath.. Except for Dehumanizer...... Which is Excellent.....

 

:yikes:

You are hereby ORDERED to go out and buy "Heaven & Hell" and/or "Mob Rules" immediately if not sooner! (or at the very least, the BLACK SABBATH: THE DIO YEARS compilation album as a cheap short cut)

 

 

Dude, I was planning on getting the Dio Years Sabbath CD.. Relax..... :P And yes, eventually I'll get around to Heaven and Hell, and Mob Rules, don't worry.. The title track to Heaven and Hell is GOOD.. Hell on the Dio concerts I have on VHS, He ALWAYS sings it.... :headbanger:

 

 

Like Keith said you have to buy Heaven&Hell and Mob Rules.(two of the greatest Metal albums ever IMO.)

 

Consider that thirded, great freakin' stuff! :banger:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • 2021 HH Donation Drive

    Please support Heavy Harmonies! The donations goal is the out-of-pocket expenses to run the main site and this board for calendar year 2021.



    76% of donation goal reached.
    Donate Sidebar by DevFuse
  • Posts

    • You brought the man out of me, so many times, easily. 
    • One of my all-time favorite Christian rock-ballads.
    • I don't mind at all. That was the only way I could make you say, "Oh God!" without it being blasphemy. 
    • For the record, I would totally check out a "Do you want to Bang your Librarian?" thread. Also, when I first glanced at this post, I thought it read, "Do you want to Bang your Libertarian?" and I immediately thought, "No way in hell does anybody here want to bang Leykis." 
    • Agree...that sounds better. Still potential here and Erik makes it listenable.    This first single could've been pretty good with a different structured chorus so hopefully other tunes are a bit better. Still not sure its going to be melodic/catchy enough for my tastes which is generally my problem with this  genre.
    • My apologies, cob, but didn't Cody say "the only thing Atheists all have in common is we do not subscribe to the myth of the deity, god or higher power, of any kind, this is it, then we are worm food, not all Atheists subscribe to the same meaning or philosophy, we don't all believe in the same science, or anything, I personally feel as though..." Sorry if I misread, but that doesn't really sound like a group that are fundamentalist in their certainty. In fact, none of that really sounded to me how you describe it.  What does intrigue me, though, is that you acknowledge that we are just a speck upon a speck upon a speck staring at a piece of dirt on the toenail of an elephant... yet religious folk believe that there's a god out there somewhere and his only concern is whether this speck upon a speck upon a speck staring at a piece of dirt on the toenail of an elephant follows the gospel or not? And not only this speck upon a speck upon a speck staring at a piece of dirt on the toenail of an elephant, but every single other speck upon a speck upon a speck staring at a piece of dirt on the toenail of an elephant that has ever existed? Of the entire universe throughout the entirety of time, all this god really cares about is whether each speck upon a speck upon a speck staring at a piece of dirt on the toenail of an elephant is following the gospel. Because if not, that speck upon a speck upon a speck staring at a piece of dirt on the toenail of an elephant is sure as heck going to hell. Sounds like the type of being I'd like to devote my single human life to.  Sorry dudes, like I say, I'm not an atheist (that I know of), and I'm sure as heck not a religious man. What do you call someone who is just honest enough to admit that I don't have a clue how we started, or why we are, or what will happen when we're dead? And I also believe that no one alive now, or whom has lived before us, has these answers either. Nor will they ever have them. No matter how steadfast someone is in their belief of whatever they believe, no one will ever be able to answer, with 100% certainty, those questions. 
    • And a small but important  update. Had an MRI scan two weeks back and just before I went in for a weeks chemo. The day I was discharged the doctor who discharged me gave me the results of the MRI scan and confirmed my feelings that the brain cancer had reduced in size, so everything it seems is going to plan.
    • I'd like to think so too, but I don't think it is. But I am always weary of what's being reported in Australian media. Are we just seeing everything from the hysterical, moronic and blown out of proportion version that the Aussie media feeds us? Or are there actually things happening outside of this country that are as hysterically panic driven as they are here? From the few other things I've heard, globally, it does seem that this variant has earned it's own little slice of worldwide panic, so I guess we'll see. This Panic First, Ask Questions Later mentality that the world has adopted is honestly an (even further) embarrassment to humanity. If I didn't have children I would confess that the time has certainly well and truly come for the human race to be nuked and made extinct. I ponder how much I hated humans in 2019. It took 40 years to build up that level of hatred. I am not even kidding to say that those 40 years of built up hatred has probably doubled, if not tripled or even quadrupled in the space of the two years since. What I think of what has become of the human race in the space of two years has no words left to describe it. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.