Jump to content

Question about Record Club editions on US


Recommended Posts

I bought several cds' on ebay lately. Most of them don't have the UPC code bar on the traycard wich is replaced with "Manufactured by Columbia House under license," or "Mfg. for BMG Direct Marketing, Inc. under license".

 

I investigate a little further and seems these are re-edition of the first pressing identified as "record club editions", and at the time a discussion about comparative quality was going through sound thecnics.

 

My question goes for all the US members. Did you note any significant diferences on this called "record club" releases concernig the sound and booklets?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've got dozens of "record club" CDs (from both Columbia House and BMG Music Club) and I have never noticed any difference in sound quality from "store bought" CDs. I believe the record club editions are, in many cases, pressed by the original labels and licensed to the clubs. Either version is fine by me.

 

I think there's been at least one other thread about this subject in the past that went into it with more depth, but I'm too lazy to go look for it right now. :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've got dozens of "record club" CDs (from both Columbia House and BMG Music Club) and I have never noticed any difference in sound quality from "store bought" CDs. I believe the record club editions are, in many cases, pressed by the original labels and licensed to the clubs. Either version is fine by me.

 

I think there's been at least one other thread about this subject in the past that went into it with more depth, but I'm too lazy to go look for it right now. :lol:

 

 

Thanks Freddy. Since we didn't have that situation in Europe, let me ask you this: Club Edition it means you would buy them on Music Clubs like Bars or something near?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've got dozens of "record club" CDs (from both Columbia House and BMG Music Club) and I have never noticed any difference in sound quality from "store bought" CDs. I believe the record club editions are, in many cases, pressed by the original labels and licensed to the clubs. Either version is fine by me.

 

I think there's been at least one other thread about this subject in the past that went into it with more depth, but I'm too lazy to go look for it right now. :lol:

 

 

Thanks Freddy. Since we didn't have that situation in Europe, let me ask you this: Club Edition it means you would buy them on Music Clubs like Bars or something near?

The record clubs we have in the US are music by mail order companies that you subscribe to. When you join a music club, they will send you so many cd's for a very low price, and then you agree to by a certain amount more at "regular club prices" until you fulfill your agreement.

 

I personally never had any problem with Columbia House cd's. The BMG ones I do not like at all and it's strictly for personal reasons. I don't like the fact that BMG Music Club is stamped on the back jewel tray, somewhere inside the booklet, and on the cd itself. Also, if you have ever compared them, the cd's from BMG were a lot thicker than store bought cd's. To me it's just not getting the original cd as it was meant to be. I'm currently trying to replace all of my BMG stamped cd's with a regular pressing and so far I have just a few yet to replace.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've got dozens of "record club" CDs (from both Columbia House and BMG Music Club) and I have never noticed any difference in sound quality from "store bought" CDs. I believe the record club editions are, in many cases, pressed by the original labels and licensed to the clubs. Either version is fine by me.

 

I think there's been at least one other thread about this subject in the past that went into it with more depth, but I'm too lazy to go look for it right now. :lol:

 

 

Thanks Freddy. Since we didn't have that situation in Europe, let me ask you this: Club Edition it means you would buy them on Music Clubs like Bars or something near?

The record clubs we have in the US are music by mail order companies that you subscribe to. When you join a music club, they will send you so many cd's for a very low price, and then you agree to by a certain amount more at "regular club prices" until you fulfill your agreement.

 

I personally never had any problem with Columbia House cd's. The BMG ones I do not like at all and it's strictly for personal reasons. I don't like the fact that BMG Music Club is stamped on the back jewel tray, somewhere inside the booklet, and on the cd itself. Also, if you have ever compared them, the cd's from BMG were a lot thicker than store bought cd's. To me it's just not getting the original cd as it was meant to be. I'm currently trying to replace all of my BMG stamped cd's with a regular pressing and so far I have just a few yet to replace.

 

 

Thanks Blue. Understood.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This reminds me also a similar situation on Europe, but perhaps worst. Its the case of the "nice price" editons.

 

They are even worst cause most of those editions doesn't have a decent booklet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This reminds me also a similar situation on Europe, but perhaps worst. Its the case of the "nice price" editons.

 

They are even worst cause most of those editions doesn't have a decent booklet.

 

 

They have tried a similar thing here in Australia. I thinks it all an attempt to compete with costs of downloads.

Here they trialled the "Just The Music" series where basically you got the disc in the plastic centre tray in a cardboard type slip case. No booklet, no plastic case...just the music. These were about $7-8 cheaper than the regulkar editions from memory.

 

I would never buy them,... although I did buy the bon jovi release simply to keep my BJ collection complete and up to date.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used to buy from Columbia House music club very often and all of the cds were of the same quality of those that came from Music stores.

 

 

The only downside would be most of those music club cds probably aren't of much interest to buyers/collectors.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think there's been at least one other thread about this subject in the past that went into it with more depth, but I'm too lazy to go look for it right now. :lol:

 

Here's the other thread on this topic from a while ago, I was feeling less lazy today :lol:

 

http://heavyharmonies.ipbhost.com/index.ph...=Columbia+House

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
I've got dozens of "record club" CDs (from both Columbia House and BMG Music Club) and I have never noticed any difference in sound quality from "store bought" CDs. I believe the record club editions are, in many cases, pressed by the original labels and licensed to the clubs. Either version is fine by me.

 

I think there's been at least one other thread about this subject in the past that went into it with more depth, but I'm too lazy to go look for it right now. :lol:

Ive sold many record club editions on cd, people seem to want them for some reason, the metallica cds by records clubs seem to sell for higher than the originals for some reason, Ive also sold many Cure from record clubs. I dont notice any difference in sound quality, in fact ,record club editions may be a little better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ive sold many record club editions on cd, people seem to want them for some reason, the metallica cds by records clubs seem to sell for higher than the originals for some reason, Ive also sold many Cure from record clubs. I dont notice any difference in sound quality, in fact ,record club editions may be a little better.

 

I do remember seeing Metallica's stuff in my BMG and Columbia House catalogs years ago, but if memory serves, Metallica do NOT allow their albums to be sold thru the clubs anymore, which would explain why record club versions of their stuff are harder to find and are therefore more valuable.

 

*EDIT* I Googled "Metallica Record Club CDs" and found this little nugget-o-trivia on the subject. I guess as Metallica got more powerful in the biz, they were able to get one of these "No Club Sales" clauses in their record contract. So you may not be able to get Metallica's stuff from a record club anymore, but thankfully, they're still meeting our Hootie and the Blowfish needs! :lol:

 

A growing number of artists such as U2, Metallica, and Smashing Pumpkins have no-club-sale provisions in their contracts because they receive more royalties from record stores than clubs. Still, you can find popular artists such as the Cardigans, Tony Braxton, Aaliyah, and Hootie and the Blowfish.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ive sold many record club editions on cd, people seem to want them for some reason, the metallica cds by records clubs seem to sell for higher than the originals for some reason, Ive also sold many Cure from record clubs. I dont notice any difference in sound quality, in fact ,record club editions may be a little better.

 

I do remember seeing Metallica's stuff in my BMG and Columbia House catalogs years ago, but if memory serves, Metallica do NOT allow their albums to be sold thru the clubs anymore, which would explain why record club versions of their stuff are harder to find and are therefore more valuable.

 

*EDIT* I Googled "Metallica Record Club CDs" and found this little nugget-o-trivia on the subject. I guess as Metallica got more powerful in the biz, they were able to get one of these "No Club Sales" clauses in their record contract. So you may not be able to get Metallica's stuff from a record club anymore, but thankfully, they're still meeting our Hootie and the Blowfish needs! :lol:

 

A growing number of artists such as U2, Metallica, and Smashing Pumpkins have no-club-sale provisions in their contracts because they receive more royalties from record stores than clubs. Still, you can find popular artists such as the Cardigans, Tony Braxton, Aaliyah, and Hootie and the Blowfish.

 

 

I never noticed to many Def Leppard cds in those clubs either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ive sold many record club editions on cd, people seem to want them for some reason, the metallica cds by records clubs seem to sell for higher than the originals for some reason, Ive also sold many Cure from record clubs. I dont notice any difference in sound quality, in fact ,record club editions may be a little better.

 

I do remember seeing Metallica's stuff in my BMG and Columbia House catalogs years ago, but if memory serves, Metallica do NOT allow their albums to be sold thru the clubs anymore, which would explain why record club versions of their stuff are harder to find and are therefore more valuable.

 

*EDIT* I Googled "Metallica Record Club CDs" and found this little nugget-o-trivia on the subject. I guess as Metallica got more powerful in the biz, they were able to get one of these "No Club Sales" clauses in their record contract. So you may not be able to get Metallica's stuff from a record club anymore, but thankfully, they're still meeting our Hootie and the Blowfish needs! :lol:

 

A growing number of artists such as U2, Metallica, and Smashing Pumpkins have no-club-sale provisions in their contracts because they receive more royalties from record stores than clubs. Still, you can find popular artists such as the Cardigans, Tony Braxton, Aaliyah, and Hootie and the Blowfish.

 

 

I never noticed to many Def Leppard cds in those clubs either.

 

Now that you mention it, I haven't either. (of course that could be due to the fact that I never look for them... :lol:)

Maybe they have one of those "No Club Sales" clauses too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ive sold many record club editions on cd, people seem to want them for some reason, the metallica cds by records clubs seem to sell for higher than the originals for some reason, Ive also sold many Cure from record clubs. I dont notice any difference in sound quality, in fact ,record club editions may be a little better.

 

I do remember seeing Metallica's stuff in my BMG and Columbia House catalogs years ago, but if memory serves, Metallica do NOT allow their albums to be sold thru the clubs anymore, which would explain why record club versions of their stuff are harder to find and are therefore more valuable.

 

*EDIT* I Googled "Metallica Record Club CDs" and found this little nugget-o-trivia on the subject. I guess as Metallica got more powerful in the biz, they were able to get one of these "No Club Sales" clauses in their record contract. So you may not be able to get Metallica's stuff from a record club anymore, but thankfully, they're still meeting our Hootie and the Blowfish needs! :lol:

 

A growing number of artists such as U2, Metallica, and Smashing Pumpkins have no-club-sale provisions in their contracts because they receive more royalties from record stores than clubs. Still, you can find popular artists such as the Cardigans, Tony Braxton, Aaliyah, and Hootie and the Blowfish.

 

 

I never noticed to many Def Leppard cds in those clubs either.

 

Now that you mention it, I haven't either. (of course that could be due to the fact that I never look for them... :lol:)

Maybe they have one of those "No Club Sales" clauses too.

 

 

I seem to remember seeing the Vault cd but none of the studio cds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Posts

    • idk guys, I think you can only polish a turd so much. It's definitely a great attempt and as whiplash1972 says, there have been a lot of such projects since, what, 2007ish? But IMO St. Anger has never been a bad album only because of the snare drum, or the lack of guitar solos, or the long songs. It's a bad album because it's an album full of bad songs. Metallica is supposed to be badass! This is not that! Listen to Invisible Kid or Purify and tell me what's even a little cool about those songs. The whole thing is just so whiny and cringey, definitely a product of its era which was the worst for metal as a genre.
    • Didn’t realise Def Leppard were a synthwave band, ‘cause these guys sound like ‘Hysteria’ era Def Leppard more than anything else I can think of. 😉 I was wondering the other day how many people miss out on good music because it is not under a label they desire. Very sad. 
    • Cold Blooded Bitch - Crown of Thorns
    • Don't forget there is a time different time zone from Australia to America.
    • Madison Talk of the Town Masquerade Roulette Might be missing.  
    • Nuff said. It's comments like these that are so helpful. Saved me 30 seconds clicking a YouTube like 😀
    • From Lions Pride Music: In the vibrant era of late ’80s and early ’90s, when Hard Rock ruled the charts and iconic bands were born in the lively streets of L.A., a lesser-known yet equally formidable force emerged from the heart of Germany – Wiesbaden to be precise. It was in this cultural backdrop that five talented musicians converged, forming a band that would redefine Melodic Hard Rock. Thus, SHEELA was born. Their creative hub was a basement rehearsal space in an old street house, which would later evolve into Markus Teske’s legendary BAZEMENT Studio. This studio would become the birthplace of several successful albums for bands like U.D.O., Vanden Plas, Dominci, The New Roses, and more. In 1995, SHEELA released their debut album, ”BURNED DOWN,” meticulously crafted and recorded at the BAZEMENT Studio. The album, showcasing a blend of powerful vocals, compelling guitar lines, and intricate arrangements, achieved instant success in Japan. Renowned magazines like BURRN and ROCK HARD recognized their potential, with the former awarding the album 87 points. ”BURNED DOWN” opens with the captivating ”LONG TIME,” a track featuring a memorable guitar line in the chorus. The album progresses through the anthemic ”READY” and the soulful ”HOLDIN’ ON,” leaving an indelible mark on the Hard Rock scene of the time. The success of the album paved the way for a tour and, later in 1995, personnel changes in the band. In the vibrant era of late ’80s and early ’90s, when Hard Rock ruled the charts and iconic bands were born in the lively streets of L.A., a lesser-known yet equally formidable force emerged from the heart of Germany – Wiesbaden to be precise. It was in this cultural backdrop that five talented musicians converged, forming a band that would redefine Melodic Hard Rock. Thus, SHEELA was born. Their creative hub was a basement rehearsal space in an old street house, which would later evolve into Markus Teske’s legendary BAZEMENT Studio. This studio would become the birthplace of several successful albums for bands like U.D.O., Vanden Plas, Dominci, The New Roses, and more. In 1995, SHEELA released their debut album, ”BURNED DOWN,” meticulously crafted and recorded at the BAZEMENT Studio. The album, showcasing a blend of powerful vocals, compelling guitar lines, and intricate arrangements, achieved instant success in Japan. Renowned magazines like BURRN and ROCK HARD recognized their potential, with the former awarding the album 87 points. ”BURNED DOWN” opens with the captivating ”LONG TIME,” a track featuring a memorable guitar line in the chorus. The album progresses through the anthemic ”READY” and the soulful ”HOLDIN’ ON,” leaving an indelible mark on the Hard Rock scene of the time. The success of the album paved the way for a tour and, later in 1995, personnel changes in the band. Their second album, ”CHANGES,” dropped in 1997, again making waves in Japan before conquering European audiences during a tour with Canadian superstars SAGA. In the subsequent years, SHEELA shared stages with legendary acts like FATES WARNING, won the KARLSBERG CHALLENGE, and made a mark in the USA by performing at the STURGIS RALLY alongside bands like STYX and REO SPEEDWAGON. The journey continued with their third album, ”STRAIGHT HEARTED ONES” (2001), featuring guest musician Michael Sadler of SAGA. SHEELA toured extensively, opening for heavyweights like NAZARETH, MANFRED MAN, POISON, and even sharing the stage with Germany’s most successful Rockband – THE SCORPIONS. However, like any great rock story, SHEELA encountered lineup changes, and in 2002, Markus Teske bid farewell, leaving Christian Moser as the sole remaining member of the original lineup. Despite the changes, SHEELA’s impact endured, with discussions and online buzz surrounding their music even in 2018. Described as ”One of Germany’s secrets,” the timeless classics ”LONG TIME” and ”BURNED DOWN” continue to resonate with fans, prompting a resurgence in interest. In 2023, SHEELA signed a landmark deal with Lions Pride Music, a renowned record label based in Denmark. This collaboration brought forth a reissue of their debut album ”Burned Down,” remixed, remastered, and adorned with a new artwork. This worldwide release on CD and Digital platforms reintroduced the timeless magic of SHEELA to a global audience, reaffirming their status as pioneers of Melodic Hard Rock. SHEELA’s journey, marked by musical evolution, international recognition, and an enduring legacy, is a testament to the band’s commitment to creating timeless Hard Rock that transcends eras. As we look back at the album that started it all, ”BURNED DOWN,” SHEELA’s legacy lives on, leaving an indelible mark on the history of German rock. Sheela is: Wolfgang Ilsy Terne – Lead Vocals & Guitars Christian Moser – Guitars & Backing Vocals Markus Teske – Keyboards & Backing Vocals Tony Spagone – Bass & Backing Vocals Jojo Nimtz – Drums & Backing Vocals Special Guests: Patricia Loesch – Backing Vocals Martin Hofmann – Backing Vocals Robert Henrich – Harp Stefan Djokic – Slide Guitar Recorded in 1995 @ Bazement Studios, Wiesbaden, Germany 1995. Re-Mixed & Re-Mastered by Markus Teske @ Bazement Studios 2023 Produced by Sheela Chris Siloma : Chris Siloma Executive Producer: Carsten Nielsen        
    • Edvard Munch's favourite band.
    • Debut album 'Portraits' out May 31.   From Art Of Melody Music / Burning Minds Music Group:   The band was founded a decade ago under the name ”Alex Mari & The Lovers”, with the aim of writing original material. Meanwhile, in order to create good chemistry between the members, the group began playing together on several live shows, performing cover songs of legendary international artists just like Queen, Toto, Police and AC/DC.   After few line-up changes, the band was finalized with three members: Alex Mari  (Michele Luppi Band, Barock Project, Ophiura, plus guest appearances as studio backing vocalist with Rhapsody of Fire) on vocals, Gianluca Pisana on drums and backing vocals, and Sebastiano Barbirato on guitar and backing vocals. For their debut album, they established their new identity with the name, Night Pleasure Hotel.   The first studio chapter of this very promising trio offers a perfect slice of classic American AOR, reminiscent of Survivor (Bickler era), Foreigner, Prism and Toto. The album features contributions from talented special guest stars –  Michele Luppi (Whitesnake), Luca Zabbini (Barock Project, PFM), Paolo Caridi (Ellefson-Soto, Reb Beach, Geoff Tate, Krell), Gianluca Tagliavini (PFM), Roberto Galli (Michele Luppi’s Heaven, Danger Zone, Wheels Of Fire) and Iarin Munari (Red Canzian, Roberto Vecchioni, Paolo Vallesi).   Night Pleasure Hotel are sure to become one of the best newcomers of the current melodic rock scene, thanks to their infectious sound, mixed and mastered by Roberto Priori (Danger Zone, Wheels Of Fire, Raintimes, StreetLore).   The release of ”Portraits” is scheduled for May 31, 2024 via Art Of Melody Music / Burning Minds Music Group. The CD booklet features introductory liner notes written by Samuele Mannini (Melodicrock.it), while cover art and CD graphics have been developed by Aeglos Art (Wheels Of Fire, Platens, StreetLore, Raintimes, Room Experience, Nightblaze).    The first single of the album, ”Just This Once”, will be launched with an official video on March 28, 2024.   Tracklist:   01. Niko 02. Just This Once 03. We Say Goodbye 04. Walking Through The Horizon 05. You And I 06. Sweet Melodies Of Rain 07. Shivers 08. What I Feel 09. Julia  10. Suddenly 11. For You 12. Quella Sera (Bonus Track)   Night Pleasure Hotel is:   Alex Mari: Lead Vocals, Backing Vocals, Bass, Guitar, Keyboards Sebastiano Barbirato: Guitar, Bass, Backing vocals Gianluca Pisana: Drums, Piano, Backing Vocals
    • Queen Shrike = Queensryche 👍
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.