Tough one Geoff, but a damn good poll! My faves all came in a row when they were in their "prime" with Sin Decade, Stripped, Scream & Spooked. I'm like you though, they really don't have a bad disc. I'm not very fond of anything before Jump the Gun...to much cheese involved I guess.
I went with Sin Decade even though it took some thought (that hurt by the way...thinking that is No filler, all killer! It was my intro to the band, therefore my fave!
JL