chocularok

I personally think the listings would be more accurate (or at least less confusing) if the word "original" was removed. When some people see that word, they think they are getting an original first pressing & not a re-release.

An 'original' is not a cdr?? What if it has NEVER been released before in ANY format? Examples: Suspicion "Hollywood Nites" Bittersweet "Loaded Up" a number of discs released by Perris Records a ton of discs on CDBABY It's that kind of hoyty toyty , nit-picking statement that makes me sick and makes you look like a complete But hey , to each their own , right? <{POST_SNAPBACK}> I think all that he meant was that most people equate "original" cd's with being silver pressed discs. If you bought a cd from your local Best Buy & got home, opened it & saw that it was printed on a cheap CDR, what would you think? And is Perris & CDBaby selling discs that are released on CDR's (& I'm not being a smart-ass here, just really wanting to know...I've got several discs I'm getting ready to order from them).

I was a little confused as to what his actual question was, too. Maybe this will help: original cd - no reissue cd - yes homemade cdr - no factory pressed cdr - yes confusing auction description - yes

I bought several cd's from Dave a few years ago...took FOREVER to get them. When they finally arrived however, he accidently sent me the wrong Joker cd. I had order the S/T cd (US band) released on Red Light Records & he sent me the other Joker S/T cd (brazil band w/ the nudie cover). A pretty nice surprise! And damn right I kept it, too!

Maybe because the Bittersweet cd is a 2cd set & that it's more reasonably priced at $14.99....

Let's not start this thing up again...Sam is selling CDR's...if you're willing to pay 50 bucks for one, whatever. I'm sure that the good people here, though, would be willing to make someone a copy on the house.

Don't know anything about the seller, but why would you want to buy a CDR? Just post a request for it here at the message board.

Ebay (& their bastard cousin, paypal) are the same way concerning matters like this...they don't give a shit unless the problem is costing THEM money. As long as it's someone elses, they could care less.

Or it's just a bullshit excuse to charge 10 bucks for shipping...either way, I'd steer clear of this guy!

Continuing the theme of this thread...just wanted to give a shout out to Lawrence (relivinthe80's)...thanks for the great trade!

Just a quick update on my situation...first reply from the seller was not very promising. He insisted that he checked all his cd's very carefully & noted ALL tab marks, creases, etc & suggested that maybe the damage occured during shipping. He then offered a refund (less shipping costs) if I returned the cd. I sent him a few scans of the damage & as politely as I could told him that it was obvious that this damage happened prior to shipping the cd, & that I didn't doubt that he checked his cd's, but he must have overlooked this one. To make a long story short (too late) he ended up refunding me 10 bucks, which was ok by me.

Ok, here we go...just wanted some other opinions to see if I was being too anal about this. I won an auction for a copy of the Cleavage - The Demo cd. The auction description listed the cd & inserts as being in "excellent condition". When it arrived, I noticed the following problems: 1) Crease running the entire length of the left hand side of the front insert (front insert improperly placed in jewel case & closed 2) Tab indentation on bottom left of front insert (again, front insert improperly placed in jewel case & closed) Now normally I would let something like these 2 flaws slide & not even mention them to the seller, but when forking over this much coin for a disc (around $70) I think it's ok to be a little picky... 3) The tab indentation mentioned above is so bad that it actually tore the front insert. This last one is the one that bugs me the most & caused me to email the seller with my list of complaints & ask for a partial refund. Any comments of thoughts on the matter would be appreciated guys. Thanks

Good riddance...I was getting sick & tired of getting outbid by this guy

I would suggest to Michael that he at least inquire about the possibility of having it pressed on silver discs...or maybe even have it done himself & just let Sam handle distribution. Isn't that the sort of arrangment Sam has with Terry & the XYZ cd? I really think he will move more product if he insists on this.

Right on...I'd give him plenty of business if they were...I'm sure we all would. I'm just not sure that he gives a rat's ass...

Actually, through one of the members here, Malebolgia, the whole deal took place...... Choc........you may as well realise that Retrospect is legitimate. It will give yourself a whole heckuva lot less stress.....and you may actually pick up some cool music in the process. However......it's completely up to you if you.... Keep rockin'!! <{POST_SNAPBACK}> It may be legit, but I can pick up cdr's much cheaper than 20 bucks a pop via trades. Until Sam clearly states on his site that he's selling CDR's, the whole thing remains a scam in my book.

Wow, that didn't take long for Sam to contact the band members...are they neighbors of his or something?

I'm VERY anal about the condition of my cd's (hell, ask my wife...) & as far as I'm concerned, the price you won the cd for should have no affect on how forgiving you should be when it comes to the description of the cd/inserts. I would email the seller & ask for around a 25% refund (in this case $5.00) since the inserts where damaged. To me water damage is the worst "defect" there is, followed closely by cut-out markings & fading. Either that, or suggest to return the cd as long as you get reimbursed the total amount you paid + your shipping costs. Just my 2 cents...

Have at it...I'm sure this jerk off isn't the only one who deserves it.

Just wondering if anyone else has run into this one yet...I won an auction back on 9/8 & sent payment via paypal soon thereafter. After waiting for 3 weeks for my item to arrive & many ignored emails I was forced to file a claim with paypal. After getting my money back & leaving negative feedback, I noticed yesterday that he had responded to my feedback by saying that he had had to close down his shop due to the hurricane. Here's the catch...he lives in Hollywood, FL which is almost 1000 miles from where the nearest hurricane hit (it's on the Atlantic coast, fer Christ's sake!). Also, he has been left positive feedback for all his other auctions which ended the same day mine did so all those got shipped. Only difference being I won my auction very cheap. Obviously, he didn't like what it sold for & is using the hurricane as a lame excuse to back out of the deal. I even contacted him again & told him that since his shop was "open" again we should go ahead & complete the transaction & that I would contact ebay & have the feedback removed. He replied by saying that since I was a dumbass & didn't watch the news & had already left feedback, he was going to "leave it at that". Needless to say, he has been put on the mailing list for several gay porn sites.

Sam's put them all up on the website now, at a SET price, hasn't he? Moot point.... <{POST_SNAPBACK}> Well, I wouldn't say that the prices are THAT set...Friction started off at $49.99 & has recently dropped to $39.99...

You're kidding, right?

Wow, that was quick...maybe if one or both of you had posted here a while back, none of the bickering would have been necessary. Glad the situation is resolved, for both you guys

Or a lobotomy.............. JL <{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I can see both sides of this, but end up siding with Mullethead. He bought the cd & thought he was getting the OBI...if he has in fact been waiting 5 months for you to come up with a replacement, that's excessive. Sounds like he got fed up with waiting for the OBI & suggested a common cd in it's place as a show of good faith on your part. And for you to say that you now have 2 sealed copies complete with the OBI's, but since this has been aired on HH he ain't getting a copy...that's just makes you come off as a jerk. Your name was never mentioned in his post, so it's not like he came here to bad mouth you & hurt your business. Do the right thing & exchange the cd for him. Just my 2 cents.