With you 100% on PC69.
I don't like Aerosmith either, but they don't fit the criteria, as I don't feel that I should love them.
I might need to add Treat - I like the sound they make, but I find the actual songs pretty dull. Hate is a bit strong though, I don't hate them.
But The Poodles would definitely fit this bill for me.
I think there's ONE song by The Poodles that I can listen to over and over again ... but the title escapes me ... which kind of says it all ...