Jump to content
heavyharmonies

Guess Dan's top 5 of 2017

Recommended Posts

Thought this might be fun, since we're about a week or two from publishing the HH top 5 lists... knowing what you know about my preferences and predilections for the off-track, what do you think my top 5 are, in order from 5 to 1?

I will say that 2017 was one of the best years in memory for quality releases, in my opinion, and looking through the lists posted here as well as the formal lists that have come in to me thus far, very little consensus in top 5. I think that if it were a top 10 or 15, you'd start to see things coalesce.

Winner gets a tongue bath from Geoff (airfare to Australia not included).

Second place gets two tongue baths.

:lol:

5. ?

4. ?

3. ?

2. ?

1. ????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did Nightwish or Within Temptation release an album last year?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, heavyharmonies said:

Winner gets a tongue bath from Geoff (airfare to Australia not included).

Second place gets two tongue baths.

 

:eek:

I think I'm gonna lose on purpose or don't participate at all...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With prizes such as that who can resist, here is my go at it...

5. Cats In Space - Scarecrow

4. Unleash The Archers - Apex

3. Harem Scarem - United

2. Threshold - Legends of the Shires

1. One Desire - S/T

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's probably easier to win the lottery but still not worth the risk with that prize.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is all very sexy and all, and I am properly aroused in participation of welcoming the winner and runner-up to my cell, uh, I mean basement... whoops, I mean house.

But what happens if I win? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Crazysam said:

With prizes such as that who can resist, here is my go at it...

5. Cats In Space - Scarecrow

4. Unleash The Archers - Apex

3. Harem Scarem - United

2. Threshold - Legends of the Shires

1. One Desire - S/T

OK, let's play... you have 2 out of 5 correct, with 1 of the 2 in the correct order.

As other people get more guesses in, it should be possible to home in on the real list. :)

41 minutes ago, Geoff said:

But what happens if I win? 

Then you give yourself a tongue bath... in other words a regular Friday night. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Even though I live in Australia. I believe Geoff and I live in separate States, so the cost would still make it prohibitive for me to participate. However, if Geoff was able to get to Victoria????..........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Darkstone said:

Even though I live in Australia. I believe Geoff and I live in separate States, so the cost would still make it prohibitive for me to participate. However, if Geoff was able to get to Victoria????..........

Yep, no worries. I'll see you tomorrow night. 

Oh, what? You haven't even put in an entry yet for this comp? That's cool. Practice makes perfect. 

I was going to have a go at this, but I only know 2 of Sam's list and feel like I'll suffer from not being familiar with those prog / semi-prog albums. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sam' post has thrown me slightly as only 2 are correct but I was sure that at least 3 should be there..... mmm 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

to help you guys out this is my shortlist for Dan's top 5....in No order

Art Nation

Eclipse

Wildness

Nocturnal Rites

Amaranthe

Cats in Space

Code Red

One Desire

Don Barnes

Night Flight Orchestra

Pinnacle Point

HEAT

Threshold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay,  I'll go with this;

5. Eclipse

4. Nocturnal Rites

3. Harem Scarem

2. Amaranthe

1. Threshold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh Geoff... tsk tsk tsk... 0 for 5.

 

(Although 3 of those are in my Honorable Mentions list.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So a question.

I was just looking through 2016 lists and I see that Dan has over 200 CD's that were on the list, mostly also rans.

So this is an age old question for me.

How are you able to properly assess a CD every 2 days?
How many times do you listen to each?
Given that they are also rans, it indicates that they were given a fair go and assessed.

And then, what do you do with the music from 200 CD's in one year?
Do you select the songs you really like for future enjoyment? Or do you just listen, say "that was reasonably good" and then file the CD and never pull it again?

This year I bought maybe 20 albums, based on samples I heard.
Now I have a shitload of stuff I do every day and don't have a lot of time.
I know 20 would be way on the light side here, but over 200? That's a lot of music in one year...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

shit so Threshold not in your top 5. ok.

this is my guess

5. Pinnacle Point

4. Code Red

3. Night Flight Orchestra

2. Cats in Space

1. One Desire 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Glen said:

shit so Threshold not in your top 5. ok.

this is my guess

5. Pinnacle Point

4. Code Red

3. Night Flight Orchestra

2. Cats in Space

1. One Desire 

I obviously know very little on this subject, but I'd be stunned if Code Red was in his top 5. One Desire and Cats In Space I'd guess are in there. Not sure why I removed them from my list, lol. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Geoff said:

I obviously know very little on this subject, but I'd be stunned if Code Red was in his top 5. One Desire and Cats In Space I'd guess are in there. Not sure why I removed them from my list, lol. 

 

only on the fact Dan said he loved it. if I recall correctly. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, CureTheSane said:

So a question.

I was just looking through 2016 lists and I see that Dan has over 200 CD's that were on the list, mostly also rans.

So this is an age old question for me.

How are you able to properly assess a CD every 2 days?
How many times do you listen to each?
Given that they are also rans, it indicates that they were given a fair go and assessed.

And then, what do you do with the music from 200 CD's in one year?
Do you select the songs you really like for future enjoyment? Or do you just listen, say "that was reasonably good" and then file the CD and never pull it again?

This year I bought maybe 20 albums, based on samples I heard.
Now I have a shitload of stuff I do every day and don't have a lot of time.
I know 20 would be way on the light side here, but over 200? That's a lot of music in one year...

1. Once upon a time everything would have been physical CDs, either sent by the label, or the majority ones I purchased. I used to do circuits of Illinois monthly hitting pawn shops and new and used CD stores. That stopped about 12 years ago when (1) the price of gas shot through the roof, and (2) CD stores disappeared and the only thing you could really find in pawn shops are rap, hip-hop, country, and gospel. Rock and metal have evaporated, at least around here. I ended up spending $20-30 just in gas and sometimes I wouldn't come home with anything.

Nowadays, the labels distribute everything digitally as downloads. The only time I get physical CDs is if they come directly from the band. Sadly, some of the labels REALLY compress the mp3s so you cannot truly gauge the quality of the product, which does the performers and producers a disservice. Sadly, we won't be going back to "the good old days"... that ship has sailed.

2. Luckily my day job frequently allows me to listen to music while I work. That's when the majority of listening and evaluation occurs over the course of a year. I also have a 128GB flash drive in my car that I keep updated with all the new releases each year as I get them. Any CDs I buy or receive in physical form I rip to high-quality mp3s and put on the drive.

3. As far as assessment, I use MusicBee as my music player at the office, which allows me to give an "album rating" from 0 to 5 stars in half-star increments, which allows me to at least roughly categorize the albums throughout the year. Top 5 contenders come from the 5-star ratings, with Honorable Mentions being the remaining 5-stars and the 4.5-star listings. In MusicBee, I can sort by rating within the year filter, so I can see all the 2017 5-star albums together, all the 4-stars, etc., which makes refining the selections a bit easier.

-Dan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Glen said:

shit so Threshold not in your top 5. ok.

this is my guess

5. Pinnacle Point

4. Code Red

3. Night Flight Orchestra

2. Cats in Space

1. One Desire 

 

Threshold is in my honorable mention list. I love me some Threshold, but their material that was most melodic and most appealing was done during the Mac era. The current material is great, but doesn't resonate with me quite as much. Also, it's a very LONG album, and as with anything prog, there's only so much self-indulgence I can listen to before I tune out... and that hurts it just a bit.

As far as your guess... 3 out of 5 correct, with 1 in the correct position. Of the 2 others, 1 is in my honorable mentions list.

Getting close... NEXT! :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmmmm... I presume 2 correct are One Desire and Cats In Space because Crazysam has also named those and had 2 OK, while Harem Scarem and Threshold have been discarded by Geoff's list. The 3rd hit from Glen I guess is Pinnacle Point. Well, here is another list to continue the game, let's see how it goes:

5. Tokyo Motor Fist

4. Cats In Space

3. Crazy Lixx

2. Pinnacle Point

1. One Desire

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, mrbandwidth said:

5. Tokyo Motor Fist

4. Cats In Space

3. Crazy Lixx

2. Pinnacle Point

1. One Desire

2 out of 5 and those 2 are in their correct slots. The other 3 are all in my Honorable Mentions list.

Gettin' closer...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

not Pinnacle Point then

next guess

5. Don Barnes

4. Cats in Space

3. Art Nation

2. Night Flight Orchestra

1. One Desire 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ahh, no sorry. Only one guess per person. Otherwise one person could just do it over and over and over. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

booooooo ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, heavyharmonies said:

1. Once upon a time everything would have been physical CDs, either sent by the label, or the majority ones I purchased. I used to do circuits of Illinois monthly hitting pawn shops and new and used CD stores. That stopped about 12 years ago when (1) the price of gas shot through the roof, and (2) CD stores disappeared and the only thing you could really find in pawn shops are rap, hip-hop, country, and gospel. Rock and metal have evaporated, at least around here. I ended up spending $20-30 just in gas and sometimes I wouldn't come home with anything.

Nowadays, the labels distribute everything digitally as downloads. The only time I get physical CDs is if they come directly from the band. Sadly, some of the labels REALLY compress the mp3s so you cannot truly gauge the quality of the product, which does the performers and producers a disservice. Sadly, we won't be going back to "the good old days"... that ship has sailed.

2. Luckily my day job frequently allows me to listen to music while I work. That's when the majority of listening and evaluation occurs over the course of a year. I also have a 128GB flash drive in my car that I keep updated with all the new releases each year as I get them. Any CDs I buy or receive in physical form I rip to high-quality mp3s and put on the drive.

3. As far as assessment, I use MusicBee as my music player at the office, which allows me to give an "album rating" from 0 to 5 stars in half-star increments, which allows me to at least roughly categorize the albums throughout the year. Top 5 contenders come from the 5-star ratings, with Honorable Mentions being the remaining 5-stars and the 4.5-star listings. In MusicBee, I can sort by rating within the year filter, so I can see all the 2017 5-star albums together, all the 4-stars, etc., which makes refining the selections a bit easier.

-Dan

Fair enough.

That's some commitment.

The problem I have when listening to new music when I'm working of driving is that I don't really listen to it like I should be.
Probably more inclined to listen more when I'm driving on long highways etc

My backlog of albums to get to is currently 186.
I'm making a concerted effort to get through them, but it's hard work.
Enjoyable, but I've needed to be tunnel visioned about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Posts

    • Love it!  Very new-breed DRN... I don't normally dig that type of thing from my favorite 80's bands, but I'm good with it here.  Once again, Daiker is all over this one. Look at Mel slide into everyone of those notes on bass.  Dude is SOOOOOOOOOOOO damn good.  Such a shame he's virtually unknown outside Portland, Oregon (and a those of you in-the-know for this type of music).
    • The guitar-work is great.  I think it's a pretty decent cover. Look, I've been a HUGE fan since 1983, so you'll be hard-pressed to get me to say anything negative about this band.  Those of you who weren't around to see them on the Pyromania and Hysteria tours... God I feel badly for you.  "Top of their game" is a HUGE understatement.  The Beatles of my era for sure.
    • Devilment - The Great And Secret Show
    • Only point I was looking to make was that I agreed with the prior post above which had mentioned being frustrated that the guys hadn't put out many new releases over the last 15 years and that it may be beneficial to work with a better producer again.  Your follow up post pointed to the time between their earlier releases being similar and I responded to explain how I felt that was different, no worries though, we just see things differently
    • Inglorious indicated a few months ago that they had finished recording the songs for their third album, hinted as being heavier than their prior releases, which should be released via Frontiers in February 2019.  The first song/video from the upcoming album is out now https://www.planetrock.com/news/rock-news/inglorious-say-heavier-third-album-is-done-and-reveal-release-date/    
    • From 84 (the year after Pyromania) until 99 they released 4 studio albums, yes, but from 2000 until 2015 they released 3 studio albums, not 2. Not really that much difference. They also released the covers album, so that was pretty much the same level of output. They still continue to tour regularly and had issues such as Campbells cancer scare and recovery from that, plus the musical landscape is vastly different to that first time scale you mention.   Really not sure what your point is here?      
    • Uh...it doesn't sound bad.  Not as raw as the original and I think that hurts this version. But...if you're gonna do a cover, get the lyrics right.  "It's the eye of the tiger, it's the dream of the fight?"  Uh... no.
    • Damn good album...Has moved up my list also. I think as of now my top 4 are probably: Kissin' Dynamite Shiraz Lane Treat Maverick I'm not even bothering listing #5 as I'm saving a spot in the top 5 for Midnite City....Almost expecting that it'll slot in at either #1 or #2. And probably a good chance Nordic Union pushes the list also. Another release I'm really digging is Hearts On Fire.  Not officially out yet but have been listening to it for a month or so from doing a premium pre order.  Not quite making my top 5 but probably in the 6-8 range at the moment.
    • Been listening to this band a lot lately....Went back to the debut as I never spent much time with that album and sort of rediscovering it....damn good. And still like the new one a lot also....Not quite as melodic as the first couple albums but still lots of interesting hooks. Really the only album that does little for me is Into the Wild Life.  There's a few good tunes...I dig I Am The Fire....But really not much that keeps my interest on that one.
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.