Jump to content
Geoff

Bands who basically copied their own song on album number two?

Recommended Posts

Anyone got some examples of this? Bands who basically re-recorded one of the most popular songs off their debut? So the songs are different tunes, but basically a complete copy of the song that was on the debut (or previous release).

 

I'd guess they were songs the bands recorded for their debut which they wholeheartedly believed would be hits, and when they weren't they thought they'd tweak it a bit, but basically try again.

 

I have four copies that really stick out for me;

 

With a little love / Stranger than love - Harem Scarem

High enough / Where you going now - Damn Yankees

Now forever after / Gotta go (Can't wage a war)' - Kingdom Come

Without the night / Headed for a heartbreak - Winger

 

For the record, I'm not having a dig at any of these bands or songs. I know some are just strikingly similar rather than actual copies, but it's just something I think of when I hear some of these songs. For the record, I love all eight songs - I think they're all fantastic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone got some examples of this? Bands who basically re-recorded one of the most popular songs off their debut? So the songs are different tunes, but basically a complete copy of the song that was on the debut (or previous release).

 

I'd guess they were songs the bands recorded for their debut which they wholeheartedly believed would be hits, and when they weren't they thought they'd tweak it a bit, but basically try again.

 

I have four copies that really stick out for me;

 

With a little love / Stranger than love - Harem Scarem

High enough / Where you going now - Damn Yankees

Now forever after / Gotta go (Can't wage a war)' - Kingdom Come

Without the night / Headed for a heartbreak - Winger

 

For the record, I'm not having a dig at any of these bands or songs. I know some are just strikingly similar rather than actual copies, but it's just something I think of when I hear some of these songs. For the record, I love all eight songs - I think they're all fantastic.

 

The Damn Yankees one is even worse cos they basically nicked the intro of 'Come Again' and the pre & chorus of 'High Enough'

 

But its not as good as either imo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always thought Without The Night and Miles Away from Winger were super similar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always thought Without The Night and Miles Away from Winger were super similar.

 

Yep, I could see that too. Jeez Kip was a handsome young man;

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMKPQKU61QI

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1knO1Ip9oEg

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Def Leppard immediately comes to mind. First single off their latest album sounds a lot like ''Pour Some Sugar On Me''

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Stryper's entire In God We Trust album is basically a clone of To Hell With The Devil, right down to the ballads being in the same position(s) in the running order!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Every Ac/Dc song ever recorded. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Stryper's entire In God We Trust album is basically a clone of To Hell With The Devil, right down to the ballads being in the same position(s) in the running order!

 

Yeah, Stryper did do that. I think each album had one or maybe two songs alone, and they were the same type of songs on each album. ;)

 

I mentioned two Kingdom Come songs, but I reckon their first two albums were extremely similar versions of each other, in their entirety. Lots of similarities.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

None have come to mind except for examples from classical composers who used to do it regularly, but I think it's a great idea as long as the 2nd time round it has improved on the 1st one - maybe based on feedback from fans (although would that be classed as remastering?)

I do love it when bands put bonus tracks on their albums with acoustic versions or remixes.

 

On a similar theme but slightly off topic, I got seriously hacked off with Faith Hill when I accidentally bought her album named Bed of Roses when I was actually wanting the album with her hit 'Take me as I am' where the chorus is singing about a bed of roses. That was a sneaky marketing web that I got caught in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I remember Duran Duran had 2 songs very close.

The Union Of The Snake and The Reflex

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Def Leppard-
  Pour Some Sugar
  Let's Get Rcked

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not their debut, but the ZZ Top song "Dipping Low" is a blatant copy of Gimmie All your Loving, to the point where one can sing the lyrics to either song over the other.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 3/10/2018 at 5:52 AM, The Rocker said:

Def Leppard-
  Pour Some Sugar
  Let's Get Rcked

That's a bit of a stretch, innit? I guess they're similar in terms on the kind of audience they'd appeal to, but if we're talking musically, or in verse or chorus structure... I don't personally see it. ;) 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Posts

    • Cool tune - massive s/t album type vibe to it. 
    • Could be. I think they have better distribution in Europe.
    • Trace - Line Of Fire Passion Play - Time Stands Still Mike + The Mechanics - The Singles 1985 - 2014 (2 CD) Frameshift - An Absence Of Empathy Lion´s Share - Dark Hours + 1 Platens - Between Two Horizons No Sweat - Tear Down The Walls (CD-single) Texas - Tired Of Being Alone Acoustic EP
    • Then later by AOR Heaven also I think? 
    • No doubt in the world he has a sound and he doesn't stray far from it... but if it's that good I'm prepared to be lenient here,
    • Also, the boulevard album is near perfection except the 1 minute of madness at the end of Slippin Away. What were they thinking??  Might be my most played album of 2017. More accurately would no 2 spot. really looking forward to seeing them again on Saturday 
    • Yeah, I love the original.
      Interestingly, Sly Stallone wanted "Another One Bites The Dust" and Queen wouldn't allow the ise, so he asked Survivor to write their version of the Queen song.
      The watched some of the movies and saw the line "you've lost the eye of the tiger", liked the line and wrote the song.
      Another footnote, for the next movie they were presented with that "you're the best... around" song and rejected it and it went on the get fame in the Karate Kid movie. Anyway, like I said, I love the original song, but to me it sounds a bit rawer than this version.
      This version doesn't suck, it's just average in the way of "what's the point"
      Nothing new, no new take on the song.
      if you're gonna redo a song like this, it has to be (as Paul Stanley would say) bombastic.
      This isn't.

      No biggie, but of all the covers are lesser versions of the originals I'll obviously have no interest.
      To cover a song you either improve it or do your own take on it.
      Simply re-recording it with newer technology and a cleaner sound etc is not very inspiring.
    • Not sure what you mean by that. You reckon this version is more AOR than the original? Bonfire are by nature a bit ballsier than Survivor in that era and this just sounds like Bonfire doing a Survivor cover, which, by nature, is a bit more hard rock than AOR... to these ears anyway. Decent cover. 
    • Why are the making the songs more AOR than the originals? Very average.
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.