Jump to content
Silverkin

Categorizing music into genres - is it good or bad for artists?

Recommended Posts

Just wondered if anyone had thoughts on this? (or if you could point me in direction to a thread where it's already been discussed).

Even though I work in a library environment so should absolutely LOVE classifying and categorising stuff I wondered if it had gone too far with music now we have all these genres and sub genres. Can't decide if it helps or hinders artists.

 

Is it more of benefit to listeners so that they identify with a certain community but could 'harm' artists in that it could pitch fans loyal to one genre against another - a bit like the big mainstream artists who give their fans 'names' like Little monsters, Beliebers etc and the Little Monsters would never listen to - or admit to listening to - anything written by Bieber regardless of whether the music was good or not. (Just for the record I'm not a Little Monster or a Belieber myself :beerbang: )

 

What got me thinking about it was the reaction I got from a fan of one band when I suggested they might like another band 'as it's similar grunge music'. He was mightily put out and said the band he was listening to was some other sub genre of metal that I'd never even heard of and the band I'd described as 'grunge' were actually another sub genre that was new to me too and he wouldn't listen to that.

Also I went to buy what I considered a mainstream album (by Hoobastank) and nearly left without it as I couldn't find it in the A-Z section of a store but was then told it's classified as Heavy Metal. Who decides to classify it as that? The band or their publicity team?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't like categorizing music myself, I say I like rock music but that's pretty much it. Whether it's soft rock, hard rock, metal, AOR, classic rock.... doesn't really matter to me.

 

Recently we've been discussing the difference between AOR and melodic rock which I personally don't make the effort to distinguish. Anyway, here's what everyone wrote:

 

http://heavyharmonies.ipbhost.com/index.php?showtopic=35277

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I love categorising music, because I'm a bit obsessive compulsive and I like having everything in its place. However, when people ask what I listen to, I always generalise and say "80's-style Melodic Rock and Metal."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I categorize all music into 3 categories....1. I like it...2. I can listen to it ...3. I can't stand it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't like categorizing music myself, I say I like rock music but that's pretty much it. Whether it's soft rock, hard rock, metal, AOR, classic rock.... doesn't really matter to me.

 

Recently we've been discussing the difference between AOR and melodic rock which I personally don't make the effort to distinguish. Anyway, here's what everyone wrote:

 

http://heavyharmonies.ipbhost.com/index.php?showtopic=35277

Thanks Simo, that was a good thread! Guess it comes down to personal taste on whether peeps think it's a good or bad thing categorizing judging from the comments there.

 

Do you reckon it does artists a disservice when music gets too narrowly categorised or does it help in some way by creating niche markets and loyal followings?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I categorize all music into 3 categories....1. I like it...2. I can listen to it ...3. I can't stand it

Hahha, me too!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I love categorising music, because I'm a bit obsessive compulsive and I like having everything in its place. However, when people ask what I listen to, I always generalise and say "80's-style Melodic Rock and Metal."

Sounds like a healthy approach :tumbsup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I categorize all music into 3 categories....1. I like it...2. I can listen to it ...3. I can't stand it

 

Yeah, it should just be that simple. I've said previously there are only two categories - 1, you like it, or 2, you don't. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I categorize all music into 3 categories....1. I like it...2. I can listen to it ...3. I can't stand it

 

What he said ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I don't like categorizing music myself, I say I like rock music but that's pretty much it. Whether it's soft rock, hard rock, metal, AOR, classic rock.... doesn't really matter to me.

 

Recently we've been discussing the difference between AOR and melodic rock which I personally don't make the effort to distinguish. Anyway, here's what everyone wrote:

 

http://heavyharmonies.ipbhost.com/index.php?showtopic=35277

Thanks Simo, that was a good thread! Guess it comes down to personal taste on whether peeps think it's a good or bad thing categorizing judging from the comments there.

 

Do you reckon it does artists a disservice when music gets too narrowly categorised or does it help in some way by creating niche markets and loyal followings?

 

 

In places like HMV, they'll categorise everything from Within Temptation to Nickelback to Pearl Jam to Slayer as 'Heavy Metal'. Presumably on the grounds that none of these bands are 'mainstream pop'.

 

I agree that some bands may have 'suffered' as a result of being categorised - either through being typcast (not all Black Metal bands sound like Mayhem, people), or through the so-called fans refusing to listen to something new simply because it isn't a genre they're comfortable with - I STILL get friends asking me how it is that I can listen to someone like Gary Numan one minute, and Amon Amarth the next.

 

Loyalty to a band is a great thing, but not when it ends up with people being blinkered to what's around them, and becoming 'elitist' about 'their' band.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So some here categorise what they like to hear into 2 categories.
1. Music

2. Not music

 

If that works for them.....

I like a cross section of many different TYPES of music, and don't like some.

Like most people, it is effective to be able to have words to describe what I like and what I don't.
I don't generally like rap, or most of the more extreme metals (death, hardcore, screamo, etc)

 

I do like HARD ROCK.

This is my preference. My tastes lean towards (but are not limited to) sleazy, 80's style)

 

The debate about genres is kind of a waste of time, simply because, genres exist, and people refer to them.

This ain't gonna change.

If I stopped referring to genres to describe what I like and what I don't, it would become an essay of descriptive words to convey it.

I'd also hate threads to be posted here, and people say "this music is shit" with no reason why, for fear of daring to mention a genre and then be accused of being closed minded or limited in taste.

I'd rather them say "this music is shit, because it's screamo vocals" or because it's to thrashy, or too power ballady, or too rappy etc.
nothing wrong with that, don't let people try to convince you there is...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There can never be too many categories to read, makes it easier to find what you are looking for, but way too many if you want to classify them on your own.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And i guess categorizing can be super helpful for, say, the 'If you liked this album then you may also like this...' arena

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like CuretheSane's approach.

 

I try to appreciate good quality music whatever the 'genre' it's been assigned. And of course, within any genre there will be good&bad quality stuff,or stuff you just can't 'get' (Experimental contemporary classical music for example- though there have been occasional pieces among that which I've quite liked)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So some here categorise what they like to hear into 2 categories.

1. Music

2. Not music

 

Who said that?

 

 

If that works for them.....

I like a cross section of many different TYPES of music, and don't like some.

Like most people, it is effective to be able to have words to describe what I like and what I don't.

I don't generally like rap, or most of the more extreme metals (death, hardcore, screamo, etc)

 

I do like HARD ROCK.

This is my preference. My tastes lean towards (but are not limited to) sleazy, 80's style)

 

The debate about genres is kind of a waste of time, simply because, genres exist, and people refer to them.

This ain't gonna change.

If I stopped referring to genres to describe what I like and what I don't, it would become an essay of descriptive words to convey it.

I'd also hate threads to be posted here, and people say "this music is shit" with no reason why, for fear of daring to mention a genre and then be accused of being closed minded or limited in taste.

I'd rather them say "this music is shit, because it's screamo vocals" or because it's to thrashy, or too power ballady, or too rappy etc.

nothing wrong with that, don't let people try to convince you there is...

 

You seem to be reading too much into this, mate. I hope it's not because of my comments in that other thread the other day? As I explained, the reason comments like "too AOR" irritate me is that it usually comes across as someone trying to suggest that it's poofter's music and that they listen to much heavier stuff, which is awesome. The fact that you actually then said you like a lot of AOR... but that a band was "too AOR" for you... it just got confusing and didn't make any sense at all.

 

If, for example, someone said they hate a song because there are too many keyboards, or the synth is too heavy... that would make sense. Especially if you are known for liking AOR without keys... just all that acoustic AOR out there. ;) But not liking something because it's "too AOR," when you actually like AOR, makes no sense to me, personally. Maybe to others it does.

 

I also like bits of absolutely anything and everything (rock-related) and therefore couldn't say I don't like something is bad because it's "too hard rock," or "too metal," or "too sleazzzy," or "too glam" or something, because I like all those genres. Something is only bad if the songs are crap. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont like Power Metal....there, I said it

 

:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont like Power Metal....there, I said it

 

:)

 

Power metal is horrible.

 

And so is prog stuff. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Geoff, your assumptions about me and AOR are wrong, but I don't think you quite understand how.
I actually said I don't like the AOR with too many synth keys (more than once)
Believe it or not, there are different degrees of AOR. You may like it all, but that doesn't mean others don't

I did take exception to your pigeon holing me as someone who classes AOR in the way you did. Not sure about classing any music in a 'gay' way, we're not at school in the 80's any more.
I've never slammed any music here. At times I've said it's not for me, but I certainly don't judge what other people like.

 

Anyway, moving on.

To Silverkin, yes, please use my description of what I like to recommend any music you think will suit me.

That's why I'm here :)

 

I find it amazing that people here are able to listen to so much music.

I guess I listened to a lot before I had a family etc, but still, people seems to be engrossed in multiple bands every week here.

Personally I need to listen to an album 5 to 10 times before I know it enough to omit the weaker songs and keep the great ones.
Wish I had more time...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Power metal is horrible.

 

And so is prog stuff. ;)

 

 

Now that just smacks of someone saying that power metal is for bogans and far too heavy for them.

 

:whistle:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I dont like Power Metal....there, I said it

 

:)

Power metal is horrible.

 

And so is prog stuff. ;)

My prog universe is early Marillion and Threshold (esp Mac era)

 

Thats about it lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are Dream Theater prog metal?
I tried so hard to get into them, but just couldn't

I have a few albums, from memory the only song i really took to was a cover of the Elton John song Love Lies Bleeding

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I dont like Power Metal....there, I said it

 

:)

 

Power metal is horrible.

 

And so is prog stuff. ;)

 

...Except the good prog stuff? :guitar:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Categorizing music is important mainly to record stores back in the days because why on earth a jazz fans waste his time in rock sections, and sometimes rock fans don't really like metal so browsing a hard rock / AOR is much more fun. In Japan, a record store called Disk Union even rent like 7-8 different stores for each genre, usually rock and metal in one store, classic and jazz is at another store, reggae, etc.

 

But for ourselves as a music fan, hm not really necessary I guess, in my library, I just sort my Cd alphabetically

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are Dream Theater prog metal?

Wikipedia says they are,if you trust them. I've never really got what makes a piece 'progressive' (although from various comments I gather they tend to be long?)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Categorizing music is important mainly to record stores back in the days because why on earth a jazz fans waste his time in rock sections, and sometimes rock fans don't really like metal so browsing a hard rock / AOR is much more fun.

Ahh so it is good more for browsability reasons to some extent? So ideally,in a record store it would be better for artists if they were shelved in multiple genres where possible? (Like the Hoobastank album I was looking for could have gone in Metal,Rock+mainstream sections)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Posts

    • Uhh... have you seen the slate of releases for early 2020? Shits all over 2019.
    • Not so fast my friend. Hold on a minute...... Without a single noteworthy release in 2020 out yet, these are ridiculous proclamations! 
    • Fap fap fap fap fap... 2020 could wind up being the very year for releases that 2019 wasn't.
    • Mediocre song, mediocre vocals.  Guy sounds like a lesser version of about seven different singers.
    • Yep, that's a good start.
    • I dig that song.  Want to hear more.
    • Yeaaah...I hate that solo.  For me, the second half of that song is awful.  The first is off the charts great.  That signature riff?  Incredible.  But when it slows down, it dies.
    • Paul  mixes both Wicked and Radio Sun, Steve features in both. Don't if he got digs down here, it mainly Melbourne where he based .Also he might come down to get a suntan (lol).  
    • From facebook: ”THE DARK DELIGHT” out on April 3rd! Swedish melodic metal band DYNAZTY to release new album ”THE DARK DELIGHT” on April 3rd. First single ”PRESENCE OF MIND” out on January 30th. Formed in Stockholm, Sweden in 2008, DYNAZTY has since released 6 albums in a mere 10 year window.  Straying from their early days of 80’s influenced Hardrock, the band has developed and refined their sound into something that merges the modern metal scene with the past, crafting something wholly unique. Today the band is comprised of highly respected and sought after musicians, active on the metal scene in more than one way. Bassist Jonathan Olsson can also be seen in both LINDEMANN and PAIN, guitarist Love Magnusson and drummer Georg Härnsten Egg frequently tours with rock legends such as DEE SNIDER and JOE LYNN TURNER. Guitarist Mikael Lavér has been featured with both LINDEMANN and JOE LYNN TURNER, while singer Nils Molin can be heard and seen around the globe with the ever rising star of fellow Swedish band AMARANTHE. DYNAZTY are now on April 3rd set to release their biggest and most engrossing album yet - ”THE DARK DELIGHT”. Singer Nils Molin says about the album: ”We pulled out all the stops, pulled no punches and held nothing back on this one. ”THE DARK DELIGHT” is the complete vision of what this band has always wanted to be”.   Spearheaded by the first single/music video ”PRESENCE OF MIND”, DYNAZTY enters the new decade with a bang. The single and music video of PRESENCE OF MIND will be released on all platforms on January 30th. ”PRESENCE OF MIND showcases the raw nature of our band and is just the kind of groovy and melodic onslaught of a song we always wanted to release as a first single”.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.