Jump to content

The Defiants (Paul Laine/Bruno Ravel/Rob Marcello) - s/t


Recommended Posts

 

 

My favourites so far are - the beautifully composed 'That's when I ll stop loving you', melodic bliss 'Underneath the stars' & 'Take me back', and 'Save me tonight' is just as good. Rest of the album is good with 'Runaway' and 'Last Kiss' being my least favourites. I think the album is definitely a grower.

 

 

Initially "That's..." was in my top 5. But it's probably 1:40-to 1:53 longer than what I'd wished for.

I get your point. Not just this song but the entire album songs except track 1 are lengthy. I really don't have an issue a song being quite long if the song structure is made in that way. But yes, not even a single song in this album is at 3 mins rang which to me is quite unusual.

 

 

doesn't seem to affect the quality though - sometimes long songs just repeat the chorus for 2 mins which is usually awful, but theres more going on here so I don't notice it as much.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 247
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Yeah, I don't actually notice any single song on here dragging. That's when and why I hate long songs, but if I hadn't seen it mentioned here already, I actually wouldn't have even noticed these songs were long. I guess that's a good thing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ha, to each their own and together alone. I've listen to X Japan's Art of Life + Fates Warning's Ivory Gates of Dream + Shadow Gallery's First Light countless times and I never get bored.

 

I can't listen to that chorus once more anytime soon.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Usually long tracks on hard rock were suffered with repetitive chorus or stretched unnecessary guitar solo,

in this case, that song is still perfectly fine with 6 minutes in, just like Estranged or November Rain, a lengthy ballad but every second of it matters

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ha, to each their own and together alone. I've listen to X Japan's Art of Life + Fates Warning's Ivory Gates of Dream + Shadow Gallery's First Light countless times and I never get bored.

 

I can't listen to that chorus once more anytime soon.

 

 

 

Just adding to the list the mythical 22:34 minutes "At Day's End" from the latest dissertation from Redemption. As the title insinuates the end seems unapproachable, like a Zeno's Paradox, but gladly that's not the case, on contrary to the Defiants track which is never ending.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Usually long tracks on hard rock were suffered with repetitive chorus or stretched unnecessary guitar solo,

in this case, that song is still perfectly fine with 6 minutes in, just like Estranged or November Rain, a lengthy ballad but every second of it matters

 

 

No way this belongs to the category of Fighting Back the Tears, the best ballad ever composed.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay.... about to say something weird here......

 

Do some of these songs on the Defiants disc almost have a Blink 182 tinge to them or am I completely crazy. I 100% felt it in at least 2 songs. If I ever stop listening to Treat, I will point out which ones.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • My Little Pony

Okay.... about to say something weird here......

 

Do some of these songs on the Defiants disc almost have a Blink 182 tinge to them or am I completely crazy. I 100% felt it in at least 2 songs. If I ever stop listening to Treat, I will point out which ones.

That's weird. You're weird. Stop being so weird.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Okay.... about to say something weird here......

 

Do some of these songs on the Defiants disc almost have a Blink 182 tinge to them or am I completely crazy. I 100% felt it in at least 2 songs. If I ever stop listening to Treat, I will point out which ones.

That's weird. You're weird. Stop being so weird.

 

 

Weird is my normal! :rofl2:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay.... about to say something weird here......

 

Do some of these songs on the Defiants disc almost have a Blink 182 tinge to them or am I completely crazy. I 100% felt it in at least 2 songs. If I ever stop listening to Treat, I will point out which ones.

Absolutely! One of those you're referring to must be ''Underneath The Stars'' but only the verse. Like I mentioned earlier some songs do have a pop punk feel to them. But it's always just parts of songs and they manage to turn them around with great hooks and harmonies. That's why they're so addictive

Link to post
Share on other sites

Not much to say that hasn't already been said. This is a brilliant album and my favourite of 2016 so far. Still can't decide on my favourite tracks...more spins needed.

 

As for the comments above re the pop/punk influence - I can definitely hear that as well - on some tracks much more than others but it's a good thing. I was more thinking 40 Ft Ringo type of thing rather than Blink 182, but I get what you're saying.

 

I'll throw 88% at this one. Very nice!

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with that pop punk reference as well....I think I hear it in a few of the songs in the second half of the album.

 

Although, I get a lot of different vibes on this album....Some Bon Jovi...Some Lynch Mob...Some Danger Danger....Some pop punk. I even get a bit of a Gotthard vibe from "That's When I'll Stop Loving You" with the way the vocals are presented in that song.

 

I really like how this album meshes all that together and Paul Laine really can sing.

 

Great album and been pretty much spinning it nonstop since the 15th. I'll be getting Treat tonight though so I'll finally be able to see how that stacks up. I have high hopes after seeing the comments in the Treat thread.

 

Not much to say that hasn't already been said. This is a brilliant album and my favourite of 2016 so far. Still can't decide on my favourite tracks...more spins needed.

As for the comments above re the pop/punk influence - I can definitely hear that as well - on some tracks much more than others but it's a good thing. I was more thinking 40 Ft Ringo type of thing rather than Blink 182, but I get what you're saying.

I'll throw 88% at this one. Very nice!

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just listened to the song When The Lights Go Down and for some reason i was having Ray Gillen visions. Jake E. Lee needs to hook up with Paul Laine

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 month later...
  • 6 months later...
  • My Little Pony

That's When I'll Stop Loving You is a great power ballad!

Yup!

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 7 months later...

Pulled this album out today as I'm pumped I should get to see these guys live at MRF5 in Chicago. Pretty awesome.

 

Have to say this album has really held up well. Still sounds fantastic to me and is really a well put together album IMO. I really like how most of the songs seem to really have some "substance" to them and aren't all just standard 3 minute songs or whatever.

 

Hoping that maybe we'll have heard much more about album #2 by the time next May rolls around.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 6 months later...

It's been almost two years since the album came out...... does anyone know if any of the band members ever mentioned a possible follow up? I can't imagine them leaving it at only one album after the great response they got for the debut

I could sure use a new instant hit like ''Love And Bullets''

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Posts

    • I already wrote a little bit about the samples. Now that the whole songs are out I got reminded why they were my favourite band until they broke up. They got some crazy energy and they're a puzzle... 4 great musicians who leave enough space for each other to shine. Even though here and there there could be a bit more space for the vocals but yeah, guitars were the concept of this album and that's fine. Trond is probably my favourite living guitar player, nobody writes riffs like him.  In my earlier post I said Trond (Teeny) sings Call of the wild. Have to correct that, it's Bernt (Flash). Next time, let Åge sing... or Trond... the song is fine but the voice is a bit underwhelming. Where does it hurt & Shadows of eternity are my favourites after the first run through, great songs with a heaviness never heard from Wig Wam. Silver linings is very melodic but I guess one or five less repetitions of the chorus would have still been enough. Hard love is actually better thsn I thought after listening to the samples, great build up. My kaleidoscope ark is a great ballad, exactly what I missed when Wig Wam wasn't there. One little point of criticism maybe... the production is veeery rough. Energetic but some mistakes could have been edited out. The first bar of the Where does it hurt verse has a little rhythm error in the palm mutes of the guitar; there was one solo that was a bit too slow somewhere, I also heard some tiny wrong notes of the singer. For a live performance that is usual but as a studio production a bit strange... at least I haven't heard things like that before on a well done record. Anyway, these are great songs and I hope that it's only the beginning of a long future. 
    • Wind Outta Sails - Fashion Police
    • Both are good. He sounds great. All fingers crossed.
    • Hypnotized and Shadows Of Eternity stand out for me and as you say it’s great to have these guys back. Really good album. Tails off slightly towards the end I think but love the heavier sound. Today has been a fine day for music! 
    • Epica - The Holographic Principle (Deluxe)  Epica - The Quantum Enigma (Deluxe) Epica - The Solace System Stream Of Passion - A War Of Our Own Xandria - Sacrificium Xandria - Theater Of Dimensions Creye - II W.E.T - Retransmission  Wig Wam - Never Say Die
    • I was referring to the appalling lack of grammar on display in the post I highlighted. 
    • Gave this a listen and been through twice so far. I guess for me, it's good but at the same time I think I'm just a little bit underwhelmed and think I liked the last album a tiny bit more overall. Basically, I dig the first 5 songs but then the second half sort of feels pretty average to me until One Final Kiss which is killer.   Still a handful of good tunes I'll initially be adding to my playlist though and we'll see how it goes after a few more listens.
    • I’m yet to play Creye but W.E.T. and Wig Wam are a brilliant way to kick off 2021. Both really solid discs.  Looking forward to Creye now! 
    • W.E.T - Retransmission Wig Wam - Never Say Die Creye - II Ratt - Invasion Of Your Privacy(Rock Candy remaster)
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.