Jump to content

Tbone / dan need help here


figgy

Recommended Posts

you better check those stats again , cdbaby takes a hefty cut of the sales.

 

Taken from their website:

 

- You set your selling price at whatever you want.

- We keep $4 per CD sold.

- We pay checks every week

 

I'd HARDLY call $4 a "hefty cut", considered they handle all payment/shipment work for you and all you have to do is send them your stuff and then just sit back and cashing the checks.

 

PLUS, with them you get GREAT online promotion having a dedicated page on their server (150,000 unique daily hits) with audio samples, artwork, YOUR OWN CUSTOMIZED info, customer reviews, etc. etc.

 

Sorry, but no one can beat CDBABY when it comes to supporting independent bands! Not even close!

 

ok fair enough , but you're talking about 95% of the bands on the site that really suck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 50
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

ok fair enough , but you're talking about 95% of the bands on the site that really suck.

 

And your aesthetic judgment about the bands has exactly *what* to do with CDBABY's commission?

 

You're slamming the site, claiming it takes a HUGE cut, then when you get called on it, your response is "well the bands suck."

 

Please.

 

:lame:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok fair enough , but you're talking about 95% of the bands on the site that really suck.

 

And your aesthetic judgment about the bands has exactly *what* to do with CDBABY's commission?

 

You're slamming the site, claiming it takes a HUGE cut, then when you get called on it, your response is "well the bands suck."

 

Please.

 

:lame:

 

Just call it how I see it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK guys I didn't mean to start anything here.I'm rather new to collecting.My knowledge of what all the terms mean is rather lacking.This is why I turned to Dan or Tbone or any other helpful hinters to clarify this for me.It wasn't meant as anything negative toward the seller.As far as elementary goes,it's only elementary for the experienced collector,not new comers longing for a little understanding.For everyone who tried to clarify I thank you.Chocularok I understand what you're saying .Thank you for the clarification !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK guys I didn't mean to start anything here.I'm rather new to collecting.My knowledge of what all the terms mean is rather lacking.This is why I turned to Dan or Tbone or any other helpful hinters to clarify this for me.It wasn't meant as anything negative toward the seller.As far as elementary goes,it's only elementary for the experienced collector,not new comers longing for a little understanding.For everyone who tried to clarify I thank you.Chocularok I understand what you're saying .Thank you for the clarification !

 

No problem...basic rule of thumb...if the auction description is confusing, a lot of times it's intentional & done for a reason. Best to avoid & look elsewhere. Happy hunting :drink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK guys I didn't mean to start anything here.I'm rather new to collecting.My knowledge of what all the terms mean is rather lacking.This is why I turned to Dan or Tbone or any other helpful hinters to clarify this for me.It wasn't meant as anything negative toward the seller.As far as elementary goes,it's only elementary for the experienced collector,not new comers longing for a little understanding.For everyone who tried to clarify I thank you.Chocularok I understand what you're saying .Thank you for the clarification !

 

No problem...basic rule of thumb...if the auction description is confusing, a lot of times it's intentional & done for a reason. Best to avoid & look elsewhere. Happy hunting :drink:

 

 

I'll keep that thought in heart.Thanks again !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People who may not look further than the title of the CD they're after maybe. Original and reissue don't belong together. He should say:

 

2005 reissue of the 19XX release on ______ Records, etc. it makes it a little more clear.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't understand why would a band want to reissue their album on CD-R. They can be overwritten, they denote cheapness, plus they blur the line between legit and non-legit recordings. I'd be afraid to sell them, as they could be mistaken for pirate copies. Is silver-pressing that expensive?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't understand why would a band want to reissue their album on CD-R. They can be overwritten, they denote cheapness, plus they blur the line between legit and non-legit recordings. I'd be afraid to sell them, as they could be mistaken for pirate copies. Is silver-pressing that expensive?

 

Kind of done the rounds this one but , apart from possible resale value, what is the problem? Do the bands make money ? Yes. Does it play in your cd player? Yes (probably , my old portable seems to be having some issues with cd-r). Is music available which would otherwise not? Yes.

 

Dan answered for me on another post about the price and if you're confident of selling a reasonable quantity (1000+?) then it looks worthwhile. I've still not seen definative figures of what quantities these re-releases are shipping but I would bet 1000 is quite a large figure for some cd's.

 

As for unclear text. I really don't understand what is wrong with something clear and simple like 'Officially licenced re-release of 198x issue. This CD is distributed on high quality CD-R. We distribute on CD-R to ensure the music you want is available at a fair price to you and the bands.'

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't understand why would a band want to reissue their album on CD-R. They can be overwritten, they denote cheapness, plus they blur the line between legit and non-legit recordings. I'd be afraid to sell them, as they could be mistaken for pirate copies. Is silver-pressing that expensive?

 

 

Ok here we go again. Let me explain clearly so Nostromo can understand.

 

Silver pressed cd's are made in a minimum quantity of 1,000. That means a band has to dish out at least $1,000 to re-press their disc.

 

CD-r's can be pressed in minimum quantities of 100 - that means a $250 investment.

 

Whatever YOU feel about the investment doesn't matter. Some people either don't want to take the risk of spending a grand on a title that may only sell 100 or 200 copies. Therefore a $250 investment is a low-risk investment that many bands are taking advantage of.

 

If you are anal about having silver cd's then shame on you for not supporting the bands - it is always the music that counts , not the packaging.

 

There are quite a few bands on CDBaby that press their discs green or black or blue or whatever they want , if you don't buy it because it 'cheapens' your collection then you are into music and/or collecting for all the wrong reasons and I personally find that offensive.

 

Being an artist and struggling to get a deal in this day and age is tough enough without having a select few dickheads trading cdr's and not actually buying the product. (I find it amazing that you will steal from the band by trading cdr's and yet won't fork out a few bucks to help them). Fortunately those 'dickheads' are in the minority. If the shoe fits.

 

End of story.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess my main concern about music on CDR is the durability of it...does anyone have any info on this? I've seen reports on how under extreme conditions (heat, cold, moisture, etc) cd's can lose some of their encoded information. And we all know that scratched up discs are prone to skipping. I just wonder how CDR's will preform over the long haul.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Then again,

a seller with 99.8% positive feedback with over 16,000 feedbacks isn't really MIS-LEADING a whole lot of people is he??

 

food for thought....

 

Jinky...didn't mean to point the finger at any specific seller. Just meant that if a buyer thinks an auction is "fishy" for whatever reason, he should go with his gut & avoid it. Sorry if you took at as a personal stab at you. :drink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Silver pressed cd's are made in a minimum quantity of 1,000.

 

Well, that's not *exactly* true, although it effectively amounts to the same thing. You can get pressed discs in quantities as low as 300, although the cost per unit is so high that you're better off getting 1,000.

 

For example, in the latest DiscMakers catalogue (keep in mind the DiscMakers is one of the more expensive replicators; you can do better pricewise):

 

4-page 4/1 booklet (4/1 means full color on one side of the sheet and black on the other), full-color disc printing, 4/1 tray card, jewel case, polywrapped:

 

Quantity 300 = $1,095 = $3.65 each

Quantity 500 = $1,290 = $2.58 each

Quantity 1,000 = $1,390 = $1.39 each (best bang for the buck without spending megabux)

Quantity 2,000 = $2,380 = $1.19 each

 

So while you can get smaller quantities done, you might as well spend the extra $300 for the additional 700 units...

 

 

If you are anal about having silver cd's then shame on you for not supporting the bands - it is always the music that counts , not the packaging.

 

Bullshit. That's your opinion. The problem surrounding this whole CDR mess is the uncertainty of it all. If the discs being distributed are CDRs, who's to say that they are legitimate as opposed to "Cousin Bob" running them off in his garage? With a pressed disc, there is at least a feeling of security (perhaps a false one) that it is a legit disc. "CDR" has a certain negative connotation to it in collecting circles, like it or not. Does that mean that all CDRs are bootlegged? No. Does that mean that all pressed discs are NOT bootlegged? No, of course not.

 

However, the currently "accepted standard" whether you agree with it or not is a pressed disc. Now, will that change in the future? Too early to tell.

 

I will say this: it's a HELL of a lot easier for someone to copy a CDR release than a pressed disc release, so that "limited release" of 100 copies could easily grow into 500 because people are simply making copies and passing them off as one of the orginal 100.

 

Is that happening? I don't know, but there's a far higher chance of that happening with a CDR release than with a pressed disc release.

 

-Dan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you are anal about having silver cd's then shame on you for not supporting the bands - it is always the music that counts , not the packaging.

 

"Bullshit. That's your opinion."

 

There's no opinions on that buddy. You either support the bands or you don't. How is that an opinion? If you choose to trade cdr's with your friend rather than going to CDbaby and purchasing it from the band THEN YOU ARE RIPPING THEM OFF. Now where does the bullshit lay? There is no excuse or justification for it so don't even try.

 

 

 

'However, the currently "accepted standard" whether you agree with it or not is a pressed disc. Now, will that change in the future? Too early to tell.'

 

Tell that to those struggling artists who can't afford to make them.

 

 

 

"I will say this: it's a HELL of a lot easier for someone to copy a CDR release than a pressed disc release, so that "limited release" of 100 copies could easily grow into 500 because people are simply making copies and passing them off as one of the orginal 100."

 

I agree , but that's why , for ebay merchants , the VERO program is in place and enforced.

It's a simple answer , buy the cd's direct from the source. How much easier should it be laid out?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's no opinions on that buddy.  You either support the bands or you don't.  How is that an opinion?  If you choose to trade cdr's with your friend rather than going to CDbaby and purchasing it from the band THEN YOU ARE RIPPING THEM OFF.  Now where does the bullshit lay?  There is no excuse or justification for it so don't even try.

 

You're arguing in circles. You say that it's bad to trade CDRs and bad to NOT buy CDRs.

 

Press the discs and there's no problem, no issue, no grey area, no suspicion, no arguments, no dissention, no doubt.

 

-Dan

 

P.S. I was never supporting trading CDRs of in-print music. If you got that from any of my posts, you're wrong. In fact I don't know why you brought up trading CDRs, since I never said anything about that to begin with.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back onto the subject of this topic.

I found nothing out of place about that wording.

I just assumed it meant not a CDR,rather than its an original pressing/release!

 

Original CD to me will always just mean its not a CDR.

First pressing,original pressing,original release etc,now they would mean exactly what they say!

 

I dunno what the fuss is about!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back onto the subject of this topic.

I found nothing out of place about that wording.

I just assumed it meant not a CDR,rather than its an original pressing/release!

 

Original CD to me will always just mean its not a CDR.

First pressing,original pressing,original release etc,now they would mean exactly what they say!

 

I dunno what the fuss is about!

 

Just some verbal acrobatics, that's all.

 

One party says it is "original CD, not home-made CD-R", while the others rightfully point to the fact that while the first statement may be valid in certain circumstances, this particular release in fact is re-issue on duplicated pro-printed CD-R.

 

So it is kinda rhetorical debate - all bits by itself are true, but put together could mislead you quite good. Since you obviously assumed it is "not CDR," you got mislead too.

 

In other words we have very rare and unique oxymoron here: an original* CD which is not homemade CD-R, and yet is ...CD-R

Funny, isnt it :)

 

* - i'm not really sure if it is really original, just temporary taking their word for it for the sake of the argument.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back onto the subject of this topic.

I found nothing out of place about that wording.

I just assumed it meant not a CDR,rather than its an original pressing/release!

 

Original CD to me will always just mean its not a CDR.

First pressing,original pressing,original release etc,now they would mean exactly what they say!

 

I dunno what the fuss is about!

 

Just some verbal acrobatics, that's all.

 

One party says it is "original CD, not home-made CD-R", while the others rightfully point to the fact that while the first statement may be valid in certain circumstances, this particular release in fact is re-issue on duplicated pro-printed CD-R.

 

So it is kinda rhetorical debate - all bits by itself are true, but put together could mislead you quite good. Since you obviously assumed it is "not CDR," you got mislead too.

 

In other words we have very rare and unique oxymoron here: an original* CD which is not homemade CD-R, and yet is ...CD-R

Funny, isnt it :)

 

* - i'm not really sure if it is really original, just temporary taking their word for it for the sake of the argument.

 

 

 

 

OH BOY..... :blink::wacko:

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Posts

    • I had the need to go to Bloomington, IL, about an hour west of me, so this time instead of just thrift stores in that town, in the wake of the JL Records trip I figured I would check and see if there were still any dedicated "record stores" there. The last time I went CD-hunting in Bloomington was almost 25 years ago. Since pawn shops stopped carrying CDs, and I only got into thrifting since I retired, for the last 20 years or so almost everything I buy has been online in one form or another. I always forget that college towns *can* be good sources of CDs, but it's soo damned inconsistent. West Lafayette (where JL Records is located) is the home of Purdue University (39,000 students), and Bloomington, IL is the home of Illinois State University (21,000 students). Why do I always forget about this?... because I live in the town with the main campus of the University of Illinois (44,000 students... bigger than either of those)... and it has NOT A SINGLE FUCKING MUSIC STORE on campus. There's only one, way off campus, and it's absolutely pathetic. It's basically a 100,000 population community with ZERO music stores. So I've gotten away from thinking about those opportunities for CD hunting... which as it turns out, has been a major mistake on my part. There are two record/CD stores on the ISU campus in Bloomington, located 2 doors apart on the same street! They both opened 20 years ago this year (after I had stopped my regular CD hunting trips to Bloomington). I wondered if, given the timing, they were both owned by the same party, but no they are competition, but friendly competition. Each owner spoke positively of the other and recommended I visit their counterpart. The two stores are North Street Records and Waiting Room Records. They are very similar to one another, and yet extremely different from JL Records from my last trip. Whereas JL was 80% CDs and 20% vinyl, both of these stores are the exact opposite. JL stocked a lot of current releases in our euro-centric genres, whereas these two stores are more what you would expect: rock = "classic rock", with very little in the way of import releases from the labels we know. That said, both stores had dedicated "heavy metal" sections, although primarily focused on death metal and thrash, as opposed to melodic, power, or prog metal. There were some interesting items of note in their used sections. Where JL typically priced things closer to full retail (used CDs $10-15, new CDs $16-25), these stores made up for their lack of variety compared to JL, in lower price points: used CDs $4-10, new CDs ($10-16). I didn't have time to take pics of the stores themselves this time out, as I was a bit rushed, but I plan to make a return trip at a more leisurely pace (although it's always going to be a PITA, as the campus parking enforcement rigorously enforces the 1-hour parking time limit or you get a $20 ticket, so moving your car every hour sucks). So going over my store-specific impressions and acquisitions... outside of a few music blu-rays for my collection, everything I picked up was for resale on eBay; stuff that I thought had enough room to justify picking up. First Waiting Room Records. This store was the larger of the two, more brightly lit, spacious, and appeared to cater more to the artsy-fartsy clientele. More of an emphasis on jazz and world music. Vintage audio equipment for sale in various places. This store had several boxes of $1 CDs (6 for $5, 13 for $10) as well as a box on the sidewalk outside the door of free cds. I availed myself of both, this cheap stuff just more out of curiosity and experimentation than anything in my wheelhouse. Lots of CD singles and radio station promos. The vast majority of what I bought here were actually bootlegs. A local collector who was getting out of physical media had sold a spate of Russian 2-on-1 boots. These were very common on eBay in the 2000-2010 period, but have dried up since then. Only really of interest to diehard completists, but depending on the artist, they can sell for fairly big bucks. As I typically do, prior to purchase I asked "any discounts for larger purchases?" I learned early on that while discounting varies greatly from store to store, if you don't ask you don't always get... so I unashamedly always ask. In this case it amounted to 10% off, which basically covered the sales tax... better than nothing.           Assassinator is a local metal band, found zero examples listed on eBay     And the carton of $1 and free CDs.   Now we move on to North Street Records. Smaller location, more dimly lit, but more my speed. Proprietor looked like he stepped out out of Duck Dynasty... a bit reserved initially, but opened up as the visit progressed. Stuff was stacked EVERYWHERE. I know I missed things, so I know I will go back to look at things more thoroughly. More rock-focused than the other store. Lots of Mobile Fidelity vinyl releases brand new, quite a large selection of CD box sets. No $1 CDs like the other place, but the pricing was better to begin with, and the discount he offered at the end was better. What caught my eye was a whole run of 13 Todd Rundgren and Utopia albums. Not inherently HH fodder per se, although certain songs definitely could fit... the material is all over the map stylistically, from pop to rock to experimental and DEVO-esque. Historically, the Utopia releases resonated with me more so than his solo efforts. These, however, were all Japanese vinyl-sleeve replica releases from 2008, part of the limited edition 80th anniversary reissue series. Looking them up online on both eBay and Discogs reveals that they are in very short supply and some of them can sell for above $50 each. They were stickered EXTREMELY reasonably to begin with at $10 each. When I checked out, he basically offered that if I bought those 13 as marked, he would knock off most of the sales tax and the other titles I had pulled would be free. I couldn't argue, as that worked out to approximately 25% off. Not to mention that his marked price on the still-sealed Dream Theater Luna Park 3CD + blu-ray set was dirt cheap to begin with. All in all, at was a great trip, and now a more semi-local source to shop at periodically.            
    • Hi, I am looking for a hard copy of this. If anyone can help, Please let me know.   Thanks,   Rick
    • New song 'Freefall' taken from the album 'Hypnotized' out July 12 through Frontiers.    
    • The definitely do put some nice effort into their videos. Yeah, that release date feels like it was a little farther out than necessary.  I feel like early June probably would've been fine to still allow plenty of promotion time and a few singles/videos. I guess I get it though.  It seems like albums die and get forgotten pretty quickly these days so the best way to give it legs is probably doing a slow burn with getting songs out there before ultimately releasing the album.
    • Ah, I love it. If they carry on like this, the videos will soon be more elaborate than the tracks. It's a pity that the album won't be released until July.
    • What a cock tease... premieres in 20 minutes...
    • 2 for 2 for me.  These guys just keep cranking out fun, catchy tunes.    
    • A little heavy on the auto-tune, but otherwise solid.
    • Heard the same and agree....snippet sounds like Disturbed or something.  I just don't get these bands sometimes.  Their popularity was made from rocking, catchy tunes....so just do that lol.   It was only a snippet of the intro I think so maybe the song will go somewhere....but I doubt it.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.